Advertisement
SNAPCLOUDBack up every photoUnlimited RAW storage, 30 days freeTry freeSample ad
Advertisement
Advertisement

Sony Tidbits…


Zeiss 55mm f1.8 vs Sony 50mm f1.8

Hunter Press sent me the video above: “Hi Andrea, the results are going to cause quite a controversy! But, I believe the lenses are basically equal. Don’t spoil the surprise! Thank you!”

Deal of the Day: Save Over 20% On Selected Cameras at Amazon UK.
Gold Box deal on the A6000 at Amazon France.
Sony a7S II Hands-on Review at Videomaker.
A7s vs A7S II ISO tests (bonus compressed/uncompressed test) by Alin Popescu.
Best 28mm legacy lenses (SonyAlphaForum).
AF Speed upgrade for the a7II and Metabones after firmware updates (Tysonrobichaudphotography).
RX1rII unboxing video by Tamrong.

Steve: “Not sure if you have published either of these previously, or not…Not rumors, but a couple of articles written by pro photographers that I just stumbled upon, both doing reviews of Sony gear, and BOTH of them concluding “I am switching from Canon to Sony, effective immediately”…
FStoppers, Nino Batista
https://fstoppers.com/bts/trial-fire-switching-sony-commercial-shoot-overnight-100963
The Breed, Dana Pennington
https://jointhebreed.com/sony-a7rii-review/”

Share this story
Community

Join the discussion

75 Responses

    1. Sure it is. You just paid four times the sum necessary to get such a good lens. I know, it is hard to admit that one has been conned.

      1. Far better sharpeness, smoother bokeh, beautiful contrast and tone. And cheaper than 501.4 zeiss A mount.
        The 501.8 A and E is a great money/price value, the same goes with the 35 A/E mount

        1. You are right, You can always find someone who has been conned even more, so you can feel better about it. The fact of the matter is that Sony is trying to sell virtually identical lenses at vastly different prices. An excellent Sony for 250 bucks and an equally excellent Sony carrying the Zeiss logo for which they pay Zeiss a handsome sum, I am sure, for 1000 bucks. In my experience, there are two types of people who buy expensive cameras and lenses:

          1) aspiring photographers concerned about the quality of their work

          and

          2) equipment fetishists concerned about the street credibility of their equipment.

          It is members of category 2 who are easy prey for the marketing departments. I do not know you or your photography, so I cannot say which category you belong to. I remember a runner-up photograph from the Wildlife Photographer of the year competition many years ago. It was taken by a Polish amateur with a Pentacon Six and a real Zeiss lens (Carl Zeiss Jena). It was very well composed, lighting was excellent and it was tack sharp. I do not know if you did watch the Hunt Report video. If you haven’t, watch at least the final two minutes where the guy is talking about what really matters in photography. Most of us, myself included, have a lot to learn about how to take excellent photographs. The money saved by buying the Sony/Sony rather than the Zeiss/Sony lens could be invested in taking a photography course taught by a master, for example. I have been on some such courses and think my photography has benefitted from it.

          1. im not saying the lens is not overpriced or not, The larger optic needed for full frame glass will of course cost more The optical design of both lens is not the same btw, its 9 element vs 7. And im not arguing that the resulted test is false..

            welcome to internet argument where everyone is not wrong..

          2. I’m not sure if you simply don’t know anything about photography, but you left out a major class of people who buy expensive cameras and lenses:
            3. Professional photographers.

            In any case, comparing FF to APS-C is fine if one owns an APS-C system. For those of us with FF bodies, it’s a level just above trolling, as are your responses on this thread in general.

            That guy’s reviews are piss-poor, not scientific at all, and if one has a FF body and they are too cheap to buy FF lenses, then they should’ve bought an APS-C body in the first place. It’s not that hard an equation to understand.

            As for me, when I eventually get the A7rII, I’ll try a pristine manual-focus Minolta 50mm lens on it with an adapter before deciding whether to get the Zeiss 55mm. But an APS-C lens will never be under consideration for that or my current FF camera.

      2. BS. There is no native E-mount FF 50mm lens 4 times cheaper. The FE 55 is a high end optic and no APS-C comparison is going to change that.

          1. worth is subjective. I compare the FE50 with other top notch lens from Nikon/Canon and even with its Sony zeiss 50 which i can never buy

          2. worth is objective.
            Compare it to the Sigma Art 50mm. Then you get the same IQ for the same price, but one stop faster.
            And usually you pay at least double the price for a one-stop-faster lens.

          3. the same goes for sigma VS Nikon/Canon high end lenses.. but if its canikon its worth it right??

          4. I’m not using that as an argument for the FE55. I stated a fact to counter the opinion that you are overpaying compared to the 50 1.8. Not true if you consider FF format.

          5. And I say, especially compared to the SEL50 f1.8, the FE55 is overpriced.

            May it be + 50% price for FF,
            may it be + 100% price for the very good IQ and build quality.
            May it be 50% cheaper, because there is no OSS

            500$ is a justified price – not more.

          6. Not so fast… The image circle of FF compared to APS-C has a 60% greater radius. That results in an image circle roughly 2.5 times larger, hence a lot more glass is necessary to cover the sensor at the same aperture.
            In addition, a lens on APS-C with comparable FOV and DOF characteristics compared to the FE55 would be a 37mm f1.2 lens which obviously doesn’t exist natively in E-mount.
            The Sony 50 f1.8 has similar FOV and DOF characteristics compared to a 75mm f2.5 lens on FF and thus cannot be compared to the FE55
            Factor in the weather sealing, superior coatings and superb sharpness wide open and there’s no surprise anymore that people are buying the FE55 in droves.
            Of course, for APS-C buy the 50 f1.8 OSS, a much smarter choice.

          7. The olympus 300mm is equivalent to a 600mm FF lens, thus not comparable to a FF 300mm lens.
            The cheapest FF 600mm option is the Tamron 150-600 at around $1100. So yes, the Olympus seems overpriced but there is no such lens in the price range you mention.

          8. We are talking about a 300mm lens here, not about FF equivalent lengths.
            And a 300mm lens does not get more expensive when it is used on a smaller sensor.

            BTW: In the m43 forum a lot of people are doing the same comparison price-wise and are thinking about getting the Canon + adapter. And I am sure, in some weeks someone pulls out a test-chart and tells that the olympus-pro lens has a 20% better IQ and therefore the higher price is justified.

          9. It doesn’t matter if we talk about equivalent FLs or not. Fact is, you are not going to get a 600mm FOV with a 300mm lens on FF, you will get that with m43. And again, a lens with similar FOV on a larger sensor has to use much more glass to project a suitable image circle.
            Basically, I compared the cheapest 600 f8 option (which is the FF equivalent to m43 300mm f4) and it is much cheaper but larger and heavier.
            I agree that the (rumored?) price of the Olympus lens is way to high. Generally, I find high end m43 lenses too expensive. Probably has to do with economies of scale.

  1. Why you want everyone’s time comparing an APS-C lens and a Full Frame one on an APS-C low resolution camera and make such a bold claim? You probably would get similar result and same conclusion with Other 50mm f/1.4. If you measure a small enough frame, every lens looks the same.

    Could the editor vest such bogus report before posting?

  2. I do respect personal opinions.

    The guy’s presentation skills are awful, saw him already multiple times and his arm- and handplaying like a rapper is (for me personally very distractive.

    Honestly, did anybody expect a hugh difference when comparing the APS-C modell with a FF one on an APS-C body? The 50/1.8 is known to be a very good performer on APS-C.

    I see a considerably difference in IQ in terms colors, contrast and overall sharpness.
    As A7 user the 50/1.8 would no choice anyway, however the Zeiss would be worth the price tag for me.

    1. I agree re your assessment of the 2 lenses. The 50/1.8 is nice, but the Zeiss really is in a different league. I’ve done some post on photos shot by my parents on their 50/1.8 and find myself reaching for the contrast and microcontrast sliders most times. Colour is obviously subjective, but to me it’s a bit mean to compare it to the Zeiss… On the other hand I’d say the 35/1.8 is almost certainly a better choice than either of the FEs for apsc.

  3. That guy tried to stir things up in dpreview forum with that video and his post got deleted. Coming to SAR is the next logical thing to do, huh? 😉

  4. Is this dip sh*t seriously comparing a FF lens against an APSC lens on a crop sensor?

    And I concur with others below, his presentation is awful.

    Please remove the video and stop linking this idiot.

    Note to others, if you take the time to hit dislike on poor videos it lowers the likelihood of them being returned in YouTube search results and so helps prevent the spread of poor content.

  5. I do think there are many people who think you can/should use full size lenses on a aps-c sensor as a way to invest into the future. For years thats what people have told them (if you plan to upgrade then….) we can see here that this is a bad idea since you loose almost all the advantages. The 50f18 gets about 13megapixels of sharpness on aps-c the 55fe18 about 32megapixels of sharpness on a fullframe (7r2) thats the difference. If there is anything to learn here is that its most of the time a bad idea to use lenses not designed for sensor size as a investment in the future unless you are very sure.

    1. During a photographic seminar of the MSOE the expert has been asked by one of the attendees about exactly that topic investment into the future.
      The reply was that its nonsense. He recommended to buy best lenses for the system one is used to and is using, independly of whether it is FF, APSC, MFT.

      1. Indeed also you delete all the advantages of the format using a FF on MFT is unless there is no MFT optic available is a downgrade. It won’t gain you much in results and you loose all the size and weight advantages. Problem is old timers (and i am not) stick to rules that have been proven wrong or at least grey in the new world where we do have correction, digital sensors, lightroom…

        For us new people (only doing this for fun the last few years) these ‘golden’ rules are confusing as h*** and you need to make up your own mind.

      2. It is not a nonsense to buy an FF lens for an APS-C if your intention is to upgrade later. That’s a personal choice, and I’m sure people are sensible enough to make any such decision for themselves.

        Size and cost apart, FF lenses normally work well on APS-C as it’s usually working within the “sweet spot” and is less impacted by any field curvature issues.

        Most of my A-mount lenses were FF, and I’ve no reason to regret that.

        MFT is, of course, a very different thing as there is no such thing as a larger format sensor so, by definition, all native lenses are MFT.

        1. You are absolutely right with your explanation. I agree for usage of primes. However I personally disliked the usage of the two Vario-Sonnars on APS-C due to the cropped focal lengths.

          Admittedly I did not exactly explain what he meant with nonsense.
          He meant it with regards to “start learning with the crop sensor, and then change to the ‘real’ format”. His opinion was that experience gained on a specific sensor format is not 1:1 transferable to another, and that – if possible – one shall start with the format that best serves one’s interest.

        2. Exactly – if you go ff then you inevitably take a hit when you sell your apsc lenses. Really it’s about buying the lens you feel most comfortable with, not the lens you’re told to buy by the man in the intetnet.

        3. You are right regarding sweet spot wrt vignetting etc. However, scaling down a lens means reducing geometric aberrations. Correcting those in larger sensor lenses means more elements or I think coatings are needed. A mft lens for example delivers a higher lp/mm value than a FF lens delivers (Olympus posts 60lp/mm mtf curves, FF lenses usually 30lp/mm). Overall, when measured wrt picture height, due to the larger sensor you get a similar/higher lp/ph value in the end for FF. However, unless the FF lens was optimised/designed to produce the same resolution wide open for similar pixel density, it could in effect be inferior _wide open_. Normalised for equivalent DOF (stopping down reduces spherical aberrations proportional to the third power of the f-stop), both perform similarly.

  6. Hunter is comparing the price of full-frame and APS-C lenses. Not entirely fair. FF lens has to provide much larger image circle at the same edge-to edge quality. Therefore it needs more engineering, better glass etc…

  7. The test is actually pretty biased – I’ve used both lenses in
    different combinations (E50 on A6000, FE55 on A6000, FE55 on A7II), and I
    can tell you that there IS a difference. As good as the E50 is, FE55 outperforms it in
    wide open corner sharpness, CA (the E50 has some nasty longitudinal CA
    which shows up as red fringes in high contrast scenes) and color
    reproduction. The differences is all the more apparent in well-lit, outdoor scenes.

    So no, the lenses are basically NOT EQUAL.

  8. These statements regarding value aren’t really worth anything unless the Sony 50mm can also do what the Zeiss 55mm does, and that is to cover a full frame image sensor. Had the video been a lot shorter and recognized the massive inequalities in comparing these two lenses, it might have been interesting to watch. Idk.

    This test shouldn’t really be a surprise who has used crop and FF cameras, but if it is, then here’s something to chew on– based on tests at DXO, the Sigma 18-35mm f/1.8 *zoom* (Nikon mount to make comparisons easy) is rated as sharper (resolving more detail/perceptual micro contrast/blahblahblah on Nikon’s APS-C D5300 than almost every Nikon, Zeiss and Sigma prime lens that’s been engineered to cover a full frame Nikon sensor. And this Sigma zoom is only bested by the Otus range, the Zeiss ZF.2 135mm f/2, and is tied with Nikon’s 85mm f/1.4 and f/1.8. (I’m probably missing some, but that’s not the point.) In the other categories (transmission, distortion, vingeting, and chroma aberration) it’s ranked higher more often than lower, usually losing the overall score due to the extra light that bumps up f/1.4 lens scores.

    I don’t say this because I’m a Sigma fanboy (though I love their lenses), nor is this a Nikon issue or a salute to DXO. It simply shows how lenses usually perform best on the sensor size they’re designed to cover, and why this test is silly. A full frame lens is a completely different animal, designed to cover a sensor with a surface area twice that of APS-C, and its job is rather more difficult than that of an APS-C lens.

  9. even compared on the crop you can definitely see how the zeiss pops and gives better separation from the background. clearly to see on the “bunch-test”. At the end I could’nt hear “very similar, very similar ” any more. But for sure, if he uses crop cameras only there is no need to pay 4 times higher price for the zeiss lens. But thus is quite different story from “I believe the lenses are basically equal”

    There are more and more such strange posts published by Andrea last time. Slowly I believe he got his lessons from Ken Rockwell about how to run a click-bite www-business with silly, instigative and controversial content.

    1. I have both. I use 50 1.8 in crop mode on A7RII and get pictures that are better than with 55 1.8. More “pop” and better colors (closer to reality).

      CA is horrible with 55 1.8, it has no pop and colors are god awful. Skin is always sick gray, greens are cold, nothing is close to reality.

  10. He should compare the IQ in a real low-light situation… hand-held, on A6000, using the best setting possible for each lens individually.

  11. Conclusion (what he doesn’t say):
    a) for an aps-c sensor, use an aps-c lens, you will save a lot of money, weight
    and get almost the same results (in some cases even more sharpness).
    b) for a ff lens, use an ff sensor. Otherwise, you will be paying more, carrying
    more, bottlenecking and not using the lens to its “full” potential.
    I used to believe in the ”future proof” argument, but as some already pointed out: use
    what suits better your current system.

    1. To me the system is E-mount and you should not buy a FE lens to be future proof, but because it is the best lens for you at that point in time for your APS-C camera.

      1. The problem is if you’re contemplating moving to ff, you know you have to replace all of your lenses. I’m not convinced by the testing anyway – I’ve seen what the 50/1.8 can do on an a5000 and wasn’t blown away (especially compared to the 35/1.8)

    2. What about using FF lenses on an APSC camera then upgrading the APSC body for a FF one after a while ? I think this would allow to keep the lenses rather than resell and buy again…

      1. It’s a good idea, in theory. Unfortunately, in reality, you get to FF knowing how to work with an 82.5mm lens, not the 55mm lens you now have. It’s a totally different animal.

        1. That’s absurd. It’s not a “totally different animal.” Going from APS-C to FF just means every lens is a bit wider. There is no FF photography law that dictates which lens you must use in order to “get to FF.”

          1. Never said there was. I said shooting with a 55 is different than shooting with an 82.5. And shooting with a 35 is different than shooting with a 24. If you enjoy shooting 85mm equivalent, then when you get to FF, you’ll want an 85mm lens.

            Forget the gear, it’s the types of photographs you take.

  12. On A6000, the cheap lens is clearly the better choice because you get OIS.
    On FF, especially A7 gen 2, the Zeiss is the better choice.
    What I really wish to have is a mixture of both lenses:
    FF, no OIS, quality level of SEL50 and priced between 250 and 350.

    1. Sure except its harder to make and clearly people using a 7R2 (where you will see the biggest difference) have proven to be able to pay a premium price so that won’t happen its simple supply and demand.

  13. The “banding issue” on the videomaker review looks very much like a posterisation problem. Perhaps that’s where the 8 bit resolution shows up.

  14. he should have compared with Sigma 60 mm 2.8 too :p in order to see if Sony 50mm 1.8 is a good lens compared to another APS-C lens 😉

  15. Opinions are always welcome; hopefully, the world is not like Yale University where kids take offense to everything and may even need a cry room to vent their frustrations. Yes, something way not agree with our own beliefs, but then again, people who want to express their opinions need to tolerate the opinions of others. Of course, one always takes others opinions as what they are – individual points of view that may or may not be useful.

  16. The side topic of that post could be :
    Does Sony have to only focus on FF line ( like now) and abandon APS-C or support both as much ?

    When you look at Canikon, the policy there is to balance the both lines
    Canon EOS camera line :
    APS-C (1.6x crop) (7) + 2 EOS M APS-C camera
    Full Frame (5)

    Nikon DSLR :
    FX : 6
    DX : 7

    Do Sony managers really know how market works, what final users really want or they just want to only compete Hasselblad and Leica on the elite market?
    IMO, for one pro photographer buying over 10k$ of gears and accessories ( not every year as some still use their 3-5 yo Canikon camera) there are dozens of mid range users who will spend 1000$ on camera…..
    Pro photographer won’t pay the Managers incomes for long time 😉

    1. The sales on ML cameras does mply that Sony is aware about marketing.

      On the other side there is an important fact about low to midrange users – my pro retailer confirms that: It is quite hard to explain a low/mid user why to spend more money on a lens than on the body.
      And this is exactly the reason for the existense of kit lenses, many low/mid users are happy about.

      The lens assortment on E mount including 3rd party is sufficient. Adding FE lenses to that there is almost anything available.

      The ones on this forum complaining about the “significant small” lens range on E mount are always the same guys.

  17. I have both 55 1.8 and 50 1.8.

    50 1.8 is better, less CA, better colors that are closer to reality. 55 colors suck ass and “3D pop” is much better with 50 1.8

    Camera is A7RII

  18. Waste of time. Look at the lab tests. The Zeiss is FAR more optically capable than the Sony 50mm 1.8, which is actually pretty weak in corner resolution (see Photozone). All of this proves is that the APS-C sensor cannot resolve what the 55mm lens can do. No duh.

  19. I have the 55 and had the 50 and to be honest the 55 is better but not 700.00 better I think depending on if you are pixel peeping most people wont notice the difference. Wide open the 55 is sharper but sharpness isn’t everything. If sony made a FF equivalent of the 50 for 200.00 more I would not have the 55.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search

Search
Advertisement
SNAPCLOUDBack up everyphotoTry freeSample ad

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

*Please also check your spam folder if you don't get the confirmation mail. And mark the mail as "non-spam" to see the future newsletter.

Advertisement
SNAPCLOUDBack up everyphotoTry freeSample ad
Advertisement
Advertisement