[shoplink 43239 ebay]
[/shoplink]
Roger from Lensrentals analyzed the build quality of the new
[shoplink 43239 ebay]Zeiss FE 35mm f/1.4 lens[/shoplink] and concludes:
“The Sony 35mm f/1.4 doesn’t give me everything I want in a lens. But it really does show that Sony is learning and improving with each product. The autofocus system is much more robust in this lens than in previous ones. The weather / dust resistance is phenomenal. The build construction is good. The optics, well, I think perhaps that may be a generation away (The one negative is that the Sony 35mm f/1.4 does not have much in the way of adjustable optics).”
Zeiss FE 35mm store price check: [shopcountry 43239].
54 Responses
Uhm, the original quote does not say ths:
The optics, well, I think perhaps that may be a generation away (The one negative is that the Sony 35mm f/1.4 does not have much in the way of adjustable optics).”
It simply says:
The optics, well, I think perhaps that may be a generation away.
Full stop. You made the last bit up.
Also, FE 35/1.4 has one of the worst MTF graphs in its class (other 35/1.4 AF lenses) and has a horrible variance:
http://www.lensrentals.com/blog/2015/10/sony-e-mount-lens-sharpness-bench-tests
The testing setup is different for FE lenses. I would not compare them to other lenses.
What is so different? The MTF charts don’t shine and this is
backed up by other tests. It’s strong point is bokeh and…that’s it.
DXO: ” the FE 35mm f1.4’s performance is excellent and ranks as the second
best FE-mount lens we’ve tested. Sharpness and Transmission results are
particularly strong, and with decent results in the other Lens Metric
categories, it’s an impressive all-round excellent performance from the
FE 35mm f1.4.”
2nd out of 5 or 7 at that time I think… :))
It’s still an average performer. I for one… didn’t like it. And I’m not the only one. Correct price for this lens is 1100-1200$. Currently it is priced as the canon mk2…and it’s nowhere near close to it.
A-Mount users have been complaining about SAL35F14G for years, yet even at the height of A-Mount, no replacement attempt was made.
Not surprised that this one sucks as well.
It doesn’t suck … but it’s no jewel either… it’s average for today’s lenses.
I only hope they will release a small 35mm 1.8 that is just as the 55mm or better. Until then … go sigma… unless you go in pouring rain 🙂
Issue with 35mm loxia F2 is that it lacks contrast wide open and mid/corner performance pretty much sucks until 5.6. Admiring Light reviewed it and said it wasn’t as good as his 300 dollar Canon 35mm F2. So we have an overpriced MF lens, a large and expensive (I won’t say overpriced) 35mm 1.4 with questionable wide open performance and a slow 35mm 2.8 with busy bokeh. I’d take the 35mm 2.8 because it is very sharp and it is small.
For the love of Jebus though- we need a 35mm F2 with AF. Sony is screwing up big time here.
Yeah, but they insist on pricing it *as* a jewel. And then the fanboys run wild with that. That’s probably where most of the snickering derives from.
There are plenty of mediocre lenses/equipment that people don’t hate on. Mostly because they are positioned right as the compromise offerings they are, and nobody is deluded.
That said, this is nowhere near the worst example of the “Sony tax”. The SEL35F28Z would be that, now made evident being that DXO has finally benchmarked the 1/6-as-expensive EF 40mm f/2.8 STM on the 5DSR.
Average? According to your graphs yes. But graphs cant measure the way the lens draws in the end. And this one is nothing short of amazing in its rendition. Wide open it has a dream like look and tons of character. DXO nor anyone else cant really measure that. It is by no way a sharpness champion wide open..by any means. But its is sharp enough there..and the rendering boosts the IQ incredibly. Clearly you depend on “reviews” instead of testing something for your self. So read some reviews which are not soooo graph oriented, but focus more on the important things….
http://diglloyd.com/blog/2015/20150407_2237-SonyA7R-Sony35f1_4-portraits.html
“the first lens that makes the platform”
http://www.stevehuffphoto.com/2015/04/21/the-sony-zeiss-35-1-4-distagon-fe-lens-review-best-35mm-lens-ever/
“best 35 mm lens ever”
…
p.s. I see that you want a 35 that is like the 55…
55/1.8, the sharpness champion. Champion without a soul, that is… Doesnt make it into my bag very often, I can tell you that 🙂
Another user opinion…
It’s average. Deal with it. You owners always get behind words
that can’t be quantified: “draws”…”rendition”…etc…
It’s like a car that it’s not fast, not beautiful, not comfortable,
handles like a boat, eats a lot of gas, lots of emissions, it’s not safe…but hey…it gives you a feeling.
Did you take into consideration that you don’t like the 55 focal length and that’s why you prefer the 35?
Another
non-user, graph eater opinion, who bases his opinion on not using the thing he trashes. Not even trying to be exact.
Its fantastic. Deal with it. You non users always hide behind SELECTED negative review statements, graphs which say nothing about overall quality, ignoring the positive reviews.
What about the reviews Ive added? Ignoring those? dont have enough graphs inside? 😀
At least I base my decisions on something other than gut feeling and “I OWN IT!…so it’s the best!”
Do you want me to get that review where it’s says it’s disappointing 🙂 … reviews without proper testing conditions and yes…graphs… are sort of worthless. They are more like a preview than a review.
Tested it 😉 … average. Looked similar to my old canon 35 L but had more contrast.
Tried to get the canon mk2 but wasn’t available at
that time. It was hard to decide whether to get a non-native
lens just because it’s better optically vs FE … glad I’ve chosen the sigma.
End of story… enjoy your lens… you paid more than you had to. At least you are enjoying it.
I own it so its the best syndrom? Do you have a feeling I suffer from that? Did you read my posts properly? Learn to read please: In the first one I clearly state that the 55 I own is soulless and it stays out of my bag. So clearly I have no issue to say that something sucks after I buy it. And I can repeat it a million times: I bought and own the 55/1.8 and it is soulless and boring! 🙂
If you tested it and it looks like your canon 35 vI, then my friend, I have to declare you blind 😀 Completely different rendering. Bokeh of the canon is terrible compared to the distagon. Even a blind person would at least notice the bokeh difference…
you know, I hope you will get your 35 that is just as sharp and boring as the 55. And you will have your happy time zooming 100% seeing every scratch in the brick wall… I rest my case…
p.s. you are still ignoring the positive reviews Ive posted in my first post
You mad?
It’s average… you paid a lot of $$$ for an average lens. Deep down you know this and it makes you mad. 🙂
That’s ok… you can always sell it.
you high?
This is your argument?
ou..I forgot you’re a mindreader 🙂 …whatever
It’s a proper argument for your “I own so
it’s the best”.
In which universe is that a proper argument? I proved to you that I dont suffer from this “I own so it’s the best” bullshit. But you obviously have issues with understanding written text, so its pointless…
I can reassure you that if I buy crap, I dont have any issues with calling it crap (like I call my 55 boring and soulless). And I have no “deep down” thoughts about about the FE 35 being a bad buy.
I see no point in this discussion anymore as I
gain nothing from trying to convince you. It’s average for me and for you not.
End of story.
I absolutely love mine. Its not average, by no means. This is a sharp lens with a beautiful bokeh. Stopped down I don’t see how it could be any sharper and wide open it’s character is just beautiful.
Exactly…stopped down…way down at 2.8.
This is a huge, heavy, expensive lens. It does a mediocre job from 1.4 to 2.8. After 2.8 who cares… the zeiss 35mm 2.8 is just as good.
Regarding the image below…keep in mind that canon is lagged behind by the canon 5dmk3 22mp sensor
Forget DXO. My lens is perfectly sharp wide open. Stopped down things always improve and the lens reaches peak probably at 5.6 like most lenses nowadays do.
Regarding 35/2.8, I have both lenses and not only are colors way better on the Distagon, also sharpness on any aperture is.
Of course…forget everything and trust you…just because…
Not DXO… but it’s still average.
The only sources that say it’s not average are subjective user opinions that actually have it.
LOL people need to justify the money they’ve spent 🙂
And others need to justify not spending it… 🙂
True! 🙂
Now look at the Canon 35mm results on a high res body (5Ds R), taken from Photozone. Not quite so rosy:
What are you trying to show us (other than to marvel at the positively stratospheric center resolution of the EF 35mm f/1.4L II USM, which beats even great ~50mm lenses) when there are no corresponding results yet for the SEL35F14Z under the same Photozone test protocols?
Of course the centre results are stratospheric in the centre on a 50mp sensor.
However, my point, as shown by that chart, is that the lens’ performance at the edges and corners is very disappointing on a modern high res sensor. It doesn’t really improve much when stopped down.
Paul decided to post a comparison with the Canon lens attached to an ageing 22mp sensor. That doesn’t exactly tell the full story when trying to assess what the Canon lens is or isn’t capable of. I know that if I’d purchased a 5DSR, I’d want newly designed lenses to be able to perform well with the sensor.
My question then would be: does *anything* (other than Otus-style oversized-image-circle extravagances, not that Photozone has results for those yet) actually resolve better than the the ~2.5-4K edge resolution we’re seeing from current-generation optics?
I might not call it “disappointing” if this is the bleeding edge of what is possible without resorting to Otus-style excess (size, weight, cost, etc.)
What is this graph supposed to show?
“… perfectly sharp wide open … Stopped down things always improve …”
Just wondering what exactly is the definition of “perfect”. I thought something perfect can’t improve.
Look at the tests below. I tested the FE and the Sigma…the sigma was clearly better optically. It can be sharper…by a lot. The corners are very soft actually and kind of a lot more distorted than it should be.
^^^ This! I entirely agree Mathias. Forget the tests, uses your own eyes. The Sony 35/1.4 FE is the best 35mm AF lens I’ve used (I’ve never tried Canon’s, only Nikon’s – and all of them, including the Sigma Art). The Sony is rather long, but not heavy, and it’s not fat. Wish it was a bit shorter, but it’s such a good lens. So why bother worrying.
DxO is full of nonsense – don’t take them seriously. Check this out: http://www.dxomark.com/Lenses/Compare/Side-by-side/Zeiss-Carl-Zeiss-Distagon-T-STAR-Otus-55mm-F14-ZF2-Nikon-on-Nikon-D800E-versus-Zeiss-Carl-Zeiss-Apo-Planar-T-Star-Otus-85mm-F14-ZF2-Nikon-on-Nikon-D800E__1242_814_1384_814
How in the world this is possible? 🙂 A sharper lens with less vignetting and lower CA has a so-called “rating” 49 while the worse lens has “rating” 50?
I didn’t mention the numbers. How is that 50 calculated and what it represents…don’t now.
I presented only the sharpness test results @1.4….which are accurate and corroborate with other tests and with what I’ve seen myself.
I actually wasn’t replying to you 🙂 No idea what you’re talking about neither… But I guess it’s ok since you’ve upvoted your own post.
I usually agree with myself…don’t you? 🙂
Yes, we understood, you don’t like that lens.
The problem with the FE 35/1.4 is not the IQ. Images from that lens are nothing short of stellar. The image quality is not the issue here.
The issue is how clumsy this lens is. It feels massive on the A7 bodies. It seems excessive: the Loxia 35/2 and the Batis 25/2 are just as good, and are a fraction of the size and weight. The 25mm Batis is a text book example of how an FE lens should be designed. Sony’s professional 35mm should have been the same.
And that’s why I’m still hoping for a Batis 35mm. The Loxia is fantastic, I especially love the unique Biogon bokeh, but the AF of a Batis lens would be very much appreciated.
One should also keep in mind that the rear end (body end) of this lens is not really sealed.
No one wants a sealed rear end.
lol
The original article does have that text, except that the latter remark is slightly earlier in the conclusion (2 paragraphs), which is why it was put in parentheses by Admin, I assume
Yes but he does not say that THIS particularly is the problem with the optics. Also, you can’t paraphrase like this, you have to let your reader know that you have rearranged the text or have inserted your own comments.
The person who runs this site isn’t a writer, nor is he smart. Just a monkey reposting things he heard from a little birdie and trying to make money off of it.
Sony RX1R II for your 35mm needs.
You will not look to other 35mm lens until the RX1R III comes out.
The new Canon 35mm L II seems pretty great. The recent tear down of the lens left the borrow lenses guys amazed at the engineering that went into it.
You could also say that the Sigma is also a great choice, especially at its current price point. But the weight of either of those lenses is comparable to the RX1R/II alone. To me, I can’t think of those as alternatives.
Never mind the body they need to be attached to as well. At least the A7 series shaves some of the weight down compared to a DSLR.
Oh, the DPreview article will be amusing.
1500 bucks? F*%! you sony. The sigma cost half the price.
I’m a nex owner and I love it but sony lens prices really suck.
“… our tests of the FE 35mm f/1.4 ZA show a LOT more distortion than tests done on a camera body using Imatest or DxO optics; we show 4% distortion where most of the on-camera testing shows 1% or less …”
So, after Leica, Zeiss is also on the bandwagon to selling us high-priced lenses as well corrected, which are not. Sony obviously does lens corrections before writing the RAW data on file. I already hear everyone yelling “the end result counts”, “who cares if the images look good”… bla bla bla. I do care (especially at this price point).
If you ask me, lenses like the Canon 35/1.4 II or the Sigma Art primes seem better value overall.
I even start to suspect that Sony is also “cheating” in the RX1 as well. A good part of the “perfect sensor lens matching” could be in fact just electronic corrections.