If you cannot afford the new Batis 85mm f/1.8 you may jump on that deal: The cheaper and faster Rokinon 85mm f/1.4 FE lens now sells for a new low price record of $249 at BestPriceOptics on eBay US (Click here). It’s manual focus only but it’s also a very good lens!
Batis links:
Zeiss Batis 85mm f/1.8 lens in US at Adorama, Bhphoto. In Eu at Amazon DE, WexUK. In Asia at Digitalrev.
Zeiss Batis 25mm f/2.0 lens at Adorama, Bhphoto. In EU at Amazon DE, WexUK. In Asia at Digitalrev.
29 Responses
Nice price.
Perhaps eye-af would be faster and accurate enough, elsewise I fail to see how any AF would be able to focus on an eyeball in a face that took up 2/3 of a scene, and not eyebrows or lashes, on a more consistant basis than MF and magnification.
With MF and magnification you know focus is where you want it, if there’s time, with AF you have a chance to focus on moving things but at f/1,4..well, again, eyelashes eyeballs. It’s a bit of a gamble.
Full-screen magnification is a great waste of time because you lose framing and can’t keep a full view of what’s going on around. EVFs either need to treble their resolution and contrast to more closely match what the eye sees so that aids are not necessary, or they need to make good PIP options where the portion you focus on only is magnified.
I can nail fast lens focus on a D800, whose OVF isn’t great, but with even the best EVFs, I have to resort to magnification, which takes time, separates the subject from their constituent parts, and removes me from the image.
Magnification is useful for still life where you have time but it is a hindrance to natural workflow otherwise.
You can nail fast focus using this lens at F1.4 with an unmagnified optical view finder? I find that very hard to believe. And if you practice using the magnified focus tool it’s not a hindrance, and the keeper rate will be much higher than using an OVF which is basically hit or miss.
Where has this very basic skill gone? Pretty much everyone I knew as a kid had a 50/1,4 and the more keen an 85/1,4 for their Nikon and Canon cameras. They used these cameras with no problem. Not one had AF back then.
And yes, it is much easier for me to ‘nail’ 85/1,4 with even a mild OVF compared to compose/magnify/recompose through an EVF on living objects. Naturally, my accuracy in both situations would be trumped by a modern AF system that properly read the scene and focused exactly on what I wanted.
But I am more accurate and much faster through a D800 OVF with the same lenses than I am through any EVF no matter the focus help. There simply is no ‘pop’ and the loss of contrast and resolution in the EVF VS what the eye sees through an OVF make it necessary to use things like magnification, which really really slows things down.
I am less accurate with a rangefinder at 1,4 at any focal length than EVF or OVF and have settled on F/2 at 90mm and 50mm though the slightly soft focus I achieve at f/1,4 when focused through a rangefinder looks great for certain photography.
Focusing a 50 mm 1.4 is easy compared to an 85 mm 1.4, two completely different animals. And I’m speaking from experience, both learning and using manual focus lenses for 30+ years. Forgive me if I’m still skeptical but I would have to see it to believe it, and I’m not talking about a lucky shot. Using magnification I can nail focus almost every time with the lens wide open, with the OVF on my D800 it was hit and miss to nail the focus. Although I usually got pretty close just winging it. But not nearly as precise as the focus magnification. All in all IMO the focus magnification is far superior.
Again, this comes down to personal experience. If you read my original post, I used the words ‘me’, ‘I’ and other pronouns denoting my personal experience.
Where I attacked EVFs was regarding resolution and contrast, which is fair. There simply is no way to equate what you see even through a D5000 through an EVF. The same glass simply doesn’t pop into focus. You must rely on aids.
And some people are fine with that. Obviously, both you and Just take are part of that cohort. And just as obvious, I am not.
And I am well aware of the differences between 85 and 50 at 1,4. It is why I mentioned both focal lengths in my post above.
Where we agree is theory: in theory focus magnification is more accurate. And it is. But current techniques remove you from the scene and zoom you in beyond what your eyes or the TTL framing see. Yes, you can nail a photo there, but then you have to zoom back out, ensure you are in focus or even move the focus point.
Through glass, you don’t need to move a focus point. You just eyeball it. And when I eyeball photos through even a crappy SLR viewfinder, I can acquire focus faster and more accurately without relying on focus points, focus recompose, and focus take movements, or leaving the scene because of magnifying in.
For work, I use magnification 100% of the time. But that is still life. Eye-balling it takes far longer. But when shooting people, I find it much more of a chore and find that the removal factor and the reliance on such focus aids removes accuracy from focus.
I can’t understand why you are trying to change my mind about my experience. You can argue on other points, but not on my experience. You can call me out for saying that focus mag is a waste of time and we could argue about that. Or you could say that EVFs are the best thing that’s ever happened. Go ahead. But you cannot argue that I find it easier to focus an 85/1,4 through an OVF than through an EVF.
Here’s a clue to resolving this debate. Like me, this guy has Ben shooting for 30 years. His eyeballs need the magnifier, just like me. I used to shoot with the naked eye but couldn’t focus on the broad side of a barn today. Without the magnifiers in EVFs I wouldn’t own a MF lens.
The only reason people could focus manual lenses on old SLRs is because they had a focus aid, the split screen microprism focus screen. Manual focus by eye on modern DSLRs is awful.
I’ve found it easier to focus without the split screen. It’s probably the reason that a rangefinder is hard for me to focus at 1,4 at 80 or 50. Again, through a D800 I had little problem with the AiS 85/1,4.
I understand that some people prefer EVFs for fine focusing, but I do not. I never had problems with it, even on lenses I was not used to, or even poor OVFs like the D300 or D200. Even with my wife’s D5000 I had no problems with longer lenses.
You are a rare breed then.
Machines are machines. They might know where you are looking at but have no idea what exactly you want. This would be a very difficult lens to use full open unless you have trap focus and a steady hand or a tripod.
Are we discussing eye-af or manual focus with image magnification?
The latter doesn’t need to know what I want beyond magnifying the part of the screen I tell it to.
You seem to be criticizing AF while Ohm below appear to be defending OVFs; I surely expected posters telling me that their Canon AF 85 1,2 nailed focus “every time” “on my cat that never sits still” “iris every time”.
I am using both mirrorless and dslr. So I definitely think it is about experience and habit. Your way of focusing is not always usable on moving objects. OVF is accurate enough for still objects. I see no reason why OVF has to be inferior than EVF. They are both very good at what they are supposed to do.
Man I wish SAR would stop posting eBay deals. I don’t consider an eBay seller a retailer to be compared to BH, Amazon, etc. even if they have 24k ratings.
Still a good deal. Hard to find for less money than that anywhere else, so I’m pretty happy they posted it. But I agree they shouldn’t post deals for a single unit (this seller has a bunch of lenses to sell, so many people will get a chance to have one, whereas if there was only one lens for sale at that price it would be gone by the time most people even see it’s for sale).
Your covered by eBay so who cares if its not Amazon…. As a seller on ebay I can tell you, it has become all about the buyer. eBay bends over backwards to make sure the buyer has an excellent experience. Even if they are trying to rip the seller off.
I got mine for 150 from ebay.
That’s a reasonable price for a manual focus lens… how many people manual focus anymore? I used to all the time because of terrible cameras in low light, but today we don’t need to worry about it. Although the prices are much higher.
Focus peaking and magnification, where the latter is more accurate then AF provided you have time. “We don’t need to worry” about low light AF nowadays? Okay.
Video guys use manual focus all the time, but they might also buy cine lenses.
It’s twenty bucks more expensive on Amazon, and it’s available with Prime shipping and their superior customer service. It’s actually ten dollars cheaper than this eBay listing if you already have a Canon or A-mount adapter.
Agreed
Does anybody know how this compare to the Samyang one? 😉
(Which cost roughtly the same without the red “37% off”)
Same lens.
Yeah, that’s my point. Don’t need to rush for a Rokinon when you can get already the Samyang for around that price.
Still I don’t know why the price difference related to the branding/naming!?
I use one of these with my a6000. There is noticable CA at f1.4 but that can be corrected in post (or stopped down). Other than that, it’s a great lens. Can’t comment on corner sharpness because of the crop factor.
Folks…COME ON! It’s practically free!!!!!
60$ delivery, I think I’ll pass
I got the Bower cine version of this lens for $249 months ago. Dunon the diff in pricing between brands either. Marketing hype doesn’t even pretend there to be any differences. ???
All manual lenses are meant to be used on tripods unless using a super wide or tele at infinity. I’ve got AF models for moving subjects but use the MF models more often. Got have both, I think….
Bottom line: I’ve got 11 lenses (Minolta AFs, Takumar primes, Samyang/Bower primes) and didn’t spend over $1200 for all of them. Zeiss, take a hike.