
Zeiss photographer Christian Dandyk had the unqiue chance to test the new Batis lenses for seven months already! He now posted his full review of the lenses at alphafotograf.de.
I have recently been asked several times which of the two Batis lenses I would recommend more. I can’t really answer this question because their areas of application are too different, even if they both feature the same high level of optics. Regardless of where I use them, they have always delivered the impressive results I demand. Photographers tend to quickly try to find fault with something – my search failed and that is a good thing as we like to say in Berlin.
Christian can be seen on the official promo video here:
Preorder links:
Zeiss Batis 85mm f/1.8 lens in US at Adorama, Bhphoto. In Eu at Amazon DE, WexUK. In Asia at Digitalrev.
Zeiss Batis 25mm f/2.0 lens at Adorama, Bhphoto. In EU at Amazon DE, WexUK. In Asia at Digitalrev.
In Europe and Asia the Loxias can be found in Stock via eBay sellers (Click here) and Digitalrev (Click here).
83 Responses
Very good review. Still don’t know if I can justify the 85. I already have a Zeiss 85 1.4 in a mount and don’t care for it that much
Well that’s not a real review, that’s advertisement !
I have no doubt that these lenses are great, but one should also publish what is wrong with the product (in a real review).
There are going to be many reviews on these lenses that will cover what’s wrong with them. This is like a car commercial, they never mention what’s wrong, they are just showing off the product.
I agree, I did just mean that it’s not a real review, I understand the writer’s logic.
This is just a promo. However, why should there be necessarily something wrong with the product?
From what I’ve read and seen the sharpness falls off around f4. Vignetting is visible until f5.6. Minor CA in the extreme corners. Built quality is in question, mine, I like metal, I see rubber and possibly plastic. Colours are not as vibrant as I would like. It’s only a 1.8. It costs a lot.
I have a mf 85mm but prefer 105-135mm I hope they make a f2 135mm soon.
Sold my beloved CZ 85 1.4 after the Batis was announced. The A-mount glass was slow, buzzy with a stupid extending focus barrel but it sure produced absolutely gorgeous colors and was tack sharp wide open. I have no doubt that the Batis will match it in QA and beat it in every other sense. Sooner or later 1.4 will come out for the E-mount, it’s inevitable, most likely similar to 35mm CZ 1.4. I’ll get that one too. Good time to be a Sony shooter with lots of great glass.
The only things I like about the 1.4 is the metal build and the stunning colour. Maybe I have a bad copy or I just need to micro adjust but I think it rather weak when it comes to sharpness. I don’t find acceptable sharpness until f2.8. I am using the a7 so it might look sharper on the a7r.
Hm, mine was tack sharp at 1.4, I had to micro adjust mine to +7, made all the difference.
I really should do that but even the things in focus are soft.
Dandyk is so different to a typical Sony camera buyer I’m really staggered they use him for the Batis Campaign.
I guess he is there to attract DSLR owners, but still… if anyone “anonymous” would write here something like “I don’t want to think about my gear, I just want to shoot” he would quickly get the typical replies (“so use your medieval DSLR” or “that’s a typical statement of people who envy Sony’s features” :D).
This is also quite sad that the cooperation with Sony/Zeiss means he doesn’t publish anything he did (still does?) with Canon cameras (e.g. on Flickr or his website). Still, if this cooperation suits him, I should applaud. And if he has any influence on how Sony bodies and lenses are designed, this surely won’t hurt the system either.
I have shot and owned so many cameras and it’s funny the A7S is the first one that truly ‘gets out of the way’. It is the only camera where I never feel like I am battling with technology or limits. I can get the shot ‘I’ want without banging up against the limits of technology. It’s also dead simple to use with all the key things I want right at my finger tips. While I am going to enjoy all the technology packed into the A7R II my A7S will still be my constant companion.
Speaking about a7S, you are instantly switching to the sensor advantage at high ISO. For me (and to be honest: for most photographers) this is a minor issue.
All FF cameras manufactured today are good enough at ISO 6400 and that’s all most people need. Sure: lazy photographers are easily attracted by a fairly clean ISO 25600 and up, but simple fact is: this kind of shots are really for family occasions (and maybe some press work – sport/concerts).
You can check Dandyk’s flickr. Most shots are with the minimal ISO available – the way it should be done. I’ve checked few dozens shots and the max ISO was 800 (used a few times).
Why is it for the lazy photographer? More elitist nonsense. Those who cannot grapple with the benefits of a camera that just works no matter what and think they are special because they don’t ‘need it’ are simply short sighted. Nobody ‘needs’ anything, but if you want to limit yourself that is fine by me.
Why? That’s fairly easy to answer. Because when using high ISO, you are trading image quality for comfort (e.g. for not carrying a tripod or larger lenses). Simple enough?
Also, by raising ISO you are getting more sharp shots at the cost of dynamic range and colours.
So you get more shots instead of better shots. That’s what I call “lazy”.
Shots above ISO 1600 are really lacking even on full frame. As I said earlier: this is an acceptable trade-off for sports or concerts. Or private usage. Or B&W “artistic” stuff, which is just another way to camouflage the sensor imperfections.
Very specialized a7S sensor might raise the “acceptable” bar by 1 EV, but that’s really nothing.
No. A tripod doesn’t stop motion. Larger lenses will gather more light, but you are assuming you will just use the largest aperture possible, which means you are trading DoF for noise. It’s about making trade offs as you say, but having the choice isn’t lazy, it’s about the technology not getting in the way where you HAVE to use a shallow DoF or a slow shutter speed on a tripod. These aren’t answers, they are work arounds.
But this is the typical answer for people who haven’t used one. Your loss.
Of course it can. Tripods are well known for stopping motion in museums etc.
No, it stops shake, not a moving subject.
You’re not very bright, are you?
This is coming from a man who thinks using a tripod is the same thing as using high ISO, but the latter is ‘lazy’. I’m sorry if all you ever shoot is statues in museums. Then yes a tripod is your go-to.
Yeah, you really aren’t too clever after all. Read our discussion once more, google “irony” and keep up the good work… :/
What that you shoot statues and that shooting low ISO’s is ‘the way it should be done’. This is for pixel peepers and nerds who marvel at how great the pixels are not the photograph. Enjoy your hobby.
Christian Dandyk wrote this:
>My Sony A7M2 on the other hand was no match for the rain and the display quickly gave out. Luckily, I always have two cameras on hand and was able to continue my work. ***The weak link was quickly identified. If any moisture hits the flash shoe, it short circuits the display.*** My otherwise unwavering trust in the camera took a few hits that day, but the Batis lenses really impressed me with their robustness<
We see this all the time when the plastic MI SHOE PROTECTOR isn't inserted, there's no way around this, there are a lot of contacts in the MI Shoe. You can see in the video, he's shooting a body without the MI Shoe protector, then on the raining clip one is in-place. Practically speaking, not loosing that MI Shoe protector is a PITA, maybe keeping it (and a spare) in a your SD Card wallet is a good idea.
Very nice looking lenses is all I want to say.
This video is pure propaganda. I can’t wish success for any company that thinks so little of its products and its customers that it would stoop so low to influence one to purchase the other.
It’s called advertising dude….Zeiss want to sell lenses and they see where the market is heading… No different from any other company. The result of living in a capitalist world…
The Century of the Self – Top Documentary Films
All commercials are propaganda. The whole purpose of any company is to convince people to buy there stuff over someone else, even if theirs is not better unless that company sells something that nobody else sells.
I needed the laugh this morning Kirby. So what your saying is that if a company has a product they are trying to sell they should not market or advertise it?
Quick somebody tell coke and Pepsi they shouldn’t use celebrities in their commercials.
I Think Nike has to discontinue Air Jordan’s right away
Did not know that Jordan was a brand of Nike…
Oh he definitely is.
How dare they try and sell their products, it’s an outrage!!
Sure. it looks like a commercial and all, but the shot of a dripping camera with lens is impressive. What they should really show is how it is lighter to pack for e-mount.
That said, you would probably need a solar charger for your batteries for these types of jobs.
I find it inappropriate rather than impressive. The camera is not built to withstand this kind of treatment. This might be fine for Dandyk, who has 2-3 bodies on tour and I’m sure Sony replaces all broken free of charge.
But an average user (for whom this video is made) has one body and might have none if he decided to use it like that in rain.
As for the weight issue: Dandyk is not a light packing, romantic traveler with a Sony body and 2 primes. He is a photographer and he travels with a lot of gear.
Either way, weight and size difference between FF DSLRs and Sony FE isn’t that big.
This is bad. I wish Sony would just make their cameras resistant in rain weather, it shouldn’t be that difficult…
Was the hot shoe cover inserted?
I don’t know. but I suspect he had two A7ii. One without hotshoe cover, and one with (which continued to work).
Really? I’ve had mine in the rain quite a bit- but I normally attempt to cover it. I might just reconsider all this now.
You’re probably safe as long as the hotshoe cover is attached. His 2nd camera did work after all.
Yes, learning curve for us all, that cover needs to be in-place, as do the HDMI port covers, same difference, contacts in there!
None of the a7 series bodies are truly weather proof. Sony stopped marketing that ages ago because of this. Most likely they might release a proper professional weather sealed a9 body.
How did you make this up?
They have never advertised them waterPROOF, just “dust and moisture resistant” and they continue to advertise them this way to this day!
Just checked A7R II features page on Sony US website and it says:
“Dust and moisture resistance
Enjoy
carefree shooting in tough environments, thanks to comprehensive dust
and moisture resistance measures that help prevent water and dust from
entering the body. These measures include sealing around the buttons and
dials, as well as a protective double-layered structure that tightly
interlocks panels and components.
Note: This camera is designed for optimal dust and moisture resistance,
but is not waterproof or splashproof.”
Link:
http://store.sony.com/-alpha-7r-ii-full-frame-mirrorless-interchangeable-lens-camera-zid27-ILCE7RM2/B/cat-27-catid-all-alpha-pro-capability
In the beginning they advertised more agressively: http://www.sonyalpharumors.com/sonys-a7-and-a7r-cameras-are-not-dust-and-moisture-resistant/
That’s because Sony took down that info down.
Good to know. I guess there is a reason to keep the shoe cap in the camera bag now.
They did use the supplied **MI SHOE PORT COVER** its no different than all those port covers on the sides of our superlative D810. Silly billy!!!
I Batis it’s pretty good. Zing!
I really don’t like these commercial, directed, user experience videos. Appreciate more reviews from sincere users.
Matt Grange said basically the same.
The sincere reviews come out after a product is readily available. The early access photographers tend to all b on the payroll.
And it for sure was the original photographer’s voice… urg..
I wonder how much he got paid to say nice things about Zeiss?
It’s a Zeiss commercial from the Zeiss Batis web page. Were you expecting serious journalism with pros and cons? 😉
Wasn’t this out a few weeks ago?
One great thing about the Sony A7r – no EXIF data needed.
One look at the sky and you know it’s an A7r and Sony’s cRAW 11+7 color.
Another compelling pice of scientific research! Oh wait, no link to your wordpress blog Anton?
I’m waiting for the day Sony releases the firmware update with lossless raw just to make you guys shut up.
Then they will start complaining how much bigger the files are.
I just got my new 128GB card, so I wouldn’t mind
I don’ t get it, can you please explain?
sony uses compressed raw files that sometimes cause artifacts in pictures of the sky. usually at night
If Nikon forces everyone to use 12bit, I think it will receive criticism as well.
Artefacts?!? You mean noise??….Which is normal…..No artifacts as far as I can see. In fact I am yet to see a single example of ‘compressiongate’
The explanation is simple, this Sam is a troll – a miserable soul posting inflammatory off-topic messages in an online community with the deliberate intent of provoking readers into an emotional response or of otherwise disrupting normal discussion, basically, a person with mental issues.
And BTW trolling has been outlawed in many countries, including UK, some US states, etc.
Loving is forgiving.
As much as I hate trolling, many of those anti-trolling laws are overly broad and leave too much to interpretation. Although that is from the American perspective where we value free speech a little differently than other nations.
He is an a**hole
One look at the jaggy edges of the building and we know you rezzed this photo up far beyond native resolution in a poor attempt to support your heavily compressed biased slander against something that has NEVER affect anyones ability to sell a photograph.
Seriously… How much does CaNikon pay their agents to create misinformation and conflate bad mathematics into real world horror stories?
Just like this sky, your comment is empty.
Bada-bing!
I love it !
*yawn*
not too sure what you’re trying to show.
There are simply no posterisation / color banding artefacts visible. May be he needs to wipe the dust of his screen…
Awesome reasoning for getting the Batis 25/2: >> 25 is a round number, one-quarter of 100, sounds good… <<
Now I just have to get it!
I didn’t find any of the images posted on the video particularly stellar. Will Zeiss pay for me to shoot with their glass in a helicopter? Lol.
One disturbing aspect of this video is the water on the camera.
I’ve seen many people say their A7 series camera was damaged by water. The Batis lenses may be well protected from water, but unfortunately the cameras are not.
In the linked article, Christian also stated that the A7’s display died because of moisture on the flash shoe, he had to use a second camera and his trust in the camera took a few hits that day.
Well, to me it doesn’t make sense to have a moisture resistant lens without a camera. However, if Sony brings out a moisture resistant A7 one day, you don’t need new lenses.
I for one am very excited for these lenses. I only hope more get confirmed soon.
Dream lenses:
18mm f2
150mm f2
That made me throw up in my mouth.
Still want the 25, but I’ll skip these videos in the future.