Advertisement
SNAPCLOUDBack up every photoUnlimited RAW storage, 30 days freeTry freeSample ad
Advertisement
Advertisement

VG900 and M mount lens test!

The NEX-VG900 camera and the lenses. Image courtesy David.

The day Sony announced the first Full Frame E-mount camera I had one question in my mind. How good will the sensor be for the use of M-mount lenses? SAR reader David tested some of these lenses on his brand new Sony NEX-VG900. It’s too early to draw any conclusion but for the first time we can see many image samples:
Here is the list of tested lenses:
1) Leica APO-Summicron 75mm (image here, lens on eBay here).
2) Leica Summilux 35mm (image here, lens on eBay here).
3) Zeiss Biogon 28mm (image here, lens on eBay here).
4) Leica Super Elmar 21mm (image here, lens on eBay here).
5) Voiglaender Heliar 15mm (image here, lens on eBay here).

Experts on SAR may tell me what they think when viewing these images. And I hope someone can do an appropriate review soon. Would like to know if there are issues or flaws using these lenses with adapters on my future NEX-9….if Sony will ever make it for me 🙂

Thanks David!!! Follow his Flickr stream.

VG900 store status check at [shopcountry 14178].

—

There is also a test at MFlenses with the Nokton 35mmf /1.2 lens.

Share this story
Community

Join the discussion

20 Responses

      1. That said – moire on A99 is a fact. Not biased opinion of a single portal build by Canon and Panasonic fanboys.

        And so Sony build a video-oriented camera just to fail miserably on a video aspect. *facepalm*

        1. EOSHD might be biased, but my eyes are not. Isn’t the ultra-crappy image from VG900 provided in the review enough to make a conclusion? This camera isn’t worth the time spent on discussing it.

          Given how extremely dissappointed I am with video quality from my a77, and how precisely Andrew Reid have described the shortcomings of the camera, I do not think EOSHD is too biased.

          a77 is a great still camera though.

          1. “extremely dissappointed” ? Oh man, you have really high requirements ;). I’m just “somewhat disappointed” and “extremely enjoying” the AF 🙂

        2. Fail miserably? ‘Oh man, you have really high requirements’, someone’d say. I just say: don’t talk about things you know nothing about 🙂

          1. My expectatins were not too high, I expected the video to be at least on par with canon crop cameras. Not even GH2.

            Should I list what’s wrong whith A77 video?

            Let’s start with AF – the most advertised feature of the camera which barely works. It worked way better on a55, now it dosn’t even try to track moving subjects.

            Codec – try to shoot a scene with lots of small moving details, like leafs, and see how the picture falls apart due to heavy compression. 28mbps for 50p is just ridiculous, 24mbps for 25p is barely acceptable for any kind of post processing. Canon has bitrate twice as high even on their mid-level cameras.

            Aliasing is significantly stronger than on Canon cameras.

            Sharpness and color rendition in video are also poor compared to canon – most likely due to codec.

            Stabilization produces a terrible jello on focus distances above 100mm. It’s better to have jerky video than artifacts like that.

            Additional crop that remains after stabilization is off.

            Can’t start shooting in M video mode immediately, need to browse through menus. Why on earth not to have camera start shooting video in the same mode, you just had for still?

            No manual audio input control

            No loupe in video! Come on, nex5n has it! Everyone have it!

            Nothing specific as you can see, only essentials that are lacking.

  1. Looking good.
    One question that is in my mind which i would love to know the answer is;
    Do you expect to see any difference in still image IQ between vg900 vs a99 vs rx1 ?
    Would it be ultimate dummy to use vg900 as primary tool over a99 also for stills?

    1. Rangefinder lenses will not work at all on an A99. So if you are a Leitz lens fan and want a FF Sony camera, it has to be E mount.

        1. Maybe, but these images on flickr are specifically tests of M mount lenses, to see if the problems shown by the NEX-7 with these lenses have been fixed.

          From a quick look I would say they have.

          1. I agree. This is highly encouraging as it proves that M mount up until 28mm remains a good fit. Even 21mm seems ok except the corners, but the edges are acceptable.

            As I use 35mm most of the time, I love that the peformance of FF sensor is briliant at that focal length. If there was a FF NEX stills cam, I would not hesitate to place my nokton 35mm 1.2 on it. I wonder, however, how would the Zeiss 35mm biogon could fare (my guess is worse because of the biogon design and the big protruding element on the back)

            I am liking what I seee.

  2. I was afraid that the video quality of the A99 will be bad , coming from 5D Mark II , but it’s really nice , apart from some moire from time to time here and there

    1. The microlenses are a big improvement over the NEX 7 and these lenses.

      The problem is that the corners are smear the detail and it gets progressively worse going from the SX35, to the SEM21 to the CV15 due to the thick anti-aliasing filter.

      The good news is that if SONY did an AA less version of the sensor like the D800E then it would most likely solve the issue for a dedicated stills camera.

  3. If these are ooc jpeg I am definitively skipping the NEX-6 & waiting for a NEX FF.
    Please SONY don’t try to over do it this is plenty for a NEX-8 the projection in the corner of the Heliar is better then on film camera!!! (if ooc jpeg)

  4. Some of the images from this camera were encouraging, but others not. See Dropbox link (in description of Flickr images) for many more samples, including aperture series on each lens. The widest lens with good performance is the Leica 28mm/2.8 (Zeiss version of the same has hideous corner smearing). I was disappointed with the Leica 21mm/3.4, compared to what is possible on the M9. So I’ve taken the VG900 back now, and will hope for an improvement with the NEX-9.

    1. David,

      the images on DropBox seems to be out of focus. It even seems that you have change the focusing between shots e.g. f8 seems to be focused very close where as at f2.8 focus is way back. In either case the sides and corners do not have object at similar distance. Given that even the center of your shots look horrid I would discount these samples completely for now.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search

Search
Advertisement
SNAPCLOUDBack up everyphotoTry freeSample ad

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

*Please also check your spam folder if you don't get the confirmation mail. And mark the mail as "non-spam" to see the future newsletter.

Advertisement
SNAPCLOUDBack up everyphotoTry freeSample ad
Advertisement
Advertisement