Advertisement
SNAPCLOUDBack up every photoUnlimited RAW storage, 30 days freeTry freeSample ad
Advertisement
Advertisement

More m43 versus Nikon thoughts (TOP and Thom Hogan).

[shoplink 23567]E-PL3[/shoplink] versus Nikon J1 size comaprison (Image Source: openpn.com).

There is a well written article at TheOnlinePhotographer (Click here) that talks about the new Nikon cameras and the competition with Micro Four Thirds: “Thing is, I’m not sure we have to do any more waiting. Yesterday seemed like a milestone to me. It was a couple of Nikons that arrived, I know that. But somehow it seemed like what really arrived was Micro 4/3.”

The Nikon and Olympus shooter Thom Hogan (Click here) is daily sharing his thoughts about the new Nikon cameras. In short the Nikon J1 and V1 are not bad cameras but there are things that he doens’t like: Price too high, no fast lens, lenses are too big, wrong marketing, still no social fucntions and “Crappy sample images”.

Read both articles to make your own opinion. As I said before, I am not a fanboy, I simply do not like that camera. That’s it!

Share this story
Community

Join the discussion

100 Responses

  1. I´m always laughing when I hear some self-proclaimed experts talking about “wrong marketing”. I´m sure the Nikon guys know what they´re doing. But some people don´t understand they´re not part of the target group.

    1. +1

      I’m sure many people here don’t like very much these new Nikon cameras, but I’m also sure that we’re not the target for these two models.

      The big problem I see for success is the price.

      1. I was to answer in that line of thought.
        Just because Nikon studied their market doesn’t mean they got it right.

        Then again, just because we argue on size, sensor size, IQ, price and the kitchen sink doesn’t mean that we got it right at predicting death on birth.

        …And speaking of phones, I can honestly say that I never thought the iPhone 1 would become such success…

        1. True. Nikon is very capable of missing the market with a anew kind of camera. Especially when their decisions are based on not undermining their other systems.

    2. The fact that most of the people here aren’t the main target for these models doesn’t mean that Nikon’s marketing knows what it is doing. Just to cite one recent example, HP is a much bigger company than Nikon which I assume means it has a much larger marketing dept–how did that work out for sales of the Touchpad?

  2. the announcement of nikon’s mirrorless only made M43 stronger.
    what was nikon thinking releaseing v1 and j1?
    like, WTF? right?

  3. How about the things that Thom likes? Seriously that Nikon bashing is getting ridiculous here.

    It is just a camera – get over it, ok?

    1. Thom specified two very specific types of shooting – “soccer moms” and a part of sports photographers. While the camera can definitely be marketed to those people, it doesn’t seem like much of an audience to base a whole new system on, not to mention that neither of the above are addressed correctly – the camera is huge and it doesn’t really have much of manual controls.
      And there are two types of people visiting here imho – photographers and those interested in the camera industry. As I see it, Nikon’s new system as it is today fails on both fronts. Hence the comments.

  4. I work within the marketing organisation of a very large, blue-chip electronics company and I can promise you that we get marketing wrong on many occasions. Just because a company is large and at the top of its segment, is no guarantee at all that marketing know what they are doing – even when backed up with consumer research, demographics etc, we don’t always get it right.

    It’s incredibly short sighted to assume that just because a company is big and successful, it always makes the right decisions.

    Are the new Nikon cameras the right decision? Who knows – noone, including Nikon will know this until a few years have passed and we can look back with hindsight at how everything played out.

    1. Does this mean you work with Intel? :p ans yes you are right. But personally i think Nikon’s 1 will do about as well as most mirrorless cams have so far but not necessarily more.

  5. I haven’t been very much in tune with Thom Hogan, but this time it looks like he stole my very exact thoughts. His list of “Things That Surprised Me” and “things people need to pay more attention to” pretty much nails it.
    Thumbs up on his post! 🙂

    1. It’s unfortunate that the second generation of the 14-42 is actually longer than the fist. They need to do something about that.

  6. I am definitely NOT in the target market. That being said…I like this quote from TheOnlinePhotographer: “Thing is, I’m not sure we have to do any more waiting. Yesterday seemed like a milestone to me. It was a couple of Nikons that arrived, I know that. But somehow it seemed like what really arrived was Micro 4/3.”’
    I find that amusing and true. It is inevitable to compare MFT to the NIkons. MFT (and maybe the new Pentax camera) are the only thing the Nikons can really be compared to. There is no contest for the new Nikons and MFT. I guess the Nikon is aimed at a market that I do not understand…so let’s move on… and get some of the highly awaited, more professional quality MFT products out on the table!!!!! (like the GF7 and the pro Pen body!)…. Have fun Nikon! 🙂

    1. +2. Totally M43 has arrived. And looking back just a month, Pany and Oly were spot on for pre-competing by releasing their recent products:

      1. The newer smaller camera models (Sure I want a GH3 or a pro Oly, but I understand the need)

      2. This year’s wonderful primes: 12mm, 25mm, and 45mm

      3. And probably most importantly, the 14-42 X that shows how small you can go even with a larger sensor than the new Nikons.

      I bet the next wave of Oly and Pany cameras will be geared towards the other end of the spectrum… the high-end users. GF “Pro”, GH3, Oly “pro” camera, etc. I can’t wait.

    2. I think it might be more accurate to state that what really arrived was mirrorless. While I’m in the m4/3 camp, I think Nikon’s entry is likely to give credibility to the mirrorless ILC format in general rather than just to m4/3.

  7. it might possibly sell in well, in countries where micro four thirds or nex are not yet established if the street price quickly comes down by quite a bit and there is very aggressive marketing, but I can’t see customers being very satisfied with it once they they have purchased it. It’s way too dumbed down even for it’s target market market (it treats women as stupid in so many ways)…

  8. When the first pen came out I knew it was 1 small step for a camera, but one giant leap for cameras.

    Thank god its worked out ok, because I got mine when they were £600!!! – Thats how confident I was about the format…(n.b. I don’t spend £600 on a car)…

    As soon as we have ISO 6400 like current 800 there will be NO reason for FF systems… unless you need an F0.95 FF dof, or you just want a peice of equpment so you can belittle others… I guess FF is not gonna totaly die then 😉

    1. >When the first pen came out I knew it was 1 small step for a camera, but one giant leap for cameras.

      You are probably confusing companies? Panasonic G1 was that giant leap you are talking about. The first Pen was just a retro-looking camera, with a horrible focusing speed and without a proper VF. Being a little smaller does not make it revolutionary IMO.

      > As soon as we have ISO 6400 like current 800 there will be NO reason for FF systems… unless you need an F0.95 FF…

      And this is a complete nonsense, sorry. The DOF control of a FF system will always be twice the better (unless you come with F0.5 micro primes or F1.4 zooms, which is not very probable), and the same can be said about its resolution potential.
      Anyway it’s true that m43 (and the likes) is slowly becoming a good enough system for more and more people. No need to exaggerate, though.

      1. “The DOF control of a FF system will always be twice the better (unless you come with F0.5 micro primes or F1.4 zooms, which is not very probable)”

        I disagree — the level of DOF is always a trade-off. I see no reason to say that one format’s shallowness of field is inherently better than another one’s. Just some formats are better suited for particular photo ops.

      2. no the G1 was an SLR rip off – the PEN was the first to say a “proper” camera does not need to be big!

        Yes DOF on a FF is more – but who the hell needs 0.95 FF – 0.95 m4/3 is enough!! get the blur tool out if you need more 🙂

      3. FF’s DoF is sometimes extremely inconvenient.
        Even worse for MF where at the edge of diffraction you sometimes still get unwanted blur in your compositions.

        1. FF sensor high iso performance allow you to control this issue. With an ff you have more creative control on your final picture.

      4. N.B. there will come a time (not too long) when the resolution, DR & ISO are so good in m4/3 size sensor that FF will be not usefull to all but NASA!

          1. Not quite – Thats the same extrapolation that says if runners keep beating the world record 100m at the rate they have been, by the year 10,000 they will be moving at near light speed 🙂

            Thing is there are technologies just round the corner that could potentialy see 3 stops improvement on the current 4/3 sensors!

            1, Back side illumination,
            2, Micro crystal refraction,
            3, Quantum film.

            so potentialy 6400 ISO looking as good as current 800 ISO… at which point the relevence of good 25k ISO is not so much (which is what FF should be good at using the same extrapolation).

          2. Yes but we filter 1/3rd the light for each pixel – so effectively we could possibly gain 1.5 stops there!

      5. The PEN was a big deal because it was the first interchangeable lens rangefinder-styled camera with a large sensor and AF. Sure, the G1 pioneered the format, but it was very conservative (go back and read the reviews around that time) and its DSLR styling didn’t really break the mold. The E-P1, with its retro look and compact body really opened up the market to what mirrorless could be, regardless of the performance it had.

  9. N.b.

    I Actualy think the nikon has some pritty good features – some I feel m4/3 should be looking at… i.e.

    Electronic shutter,
    60fps shooting (not refocusing)
    10fps shooting (refocusing)
    1/16000 shutter speed,
    240fps video.

    All things I hope get included (& bettered) in the GH3, (and future pens).

    By far the biggest threat to m4/3 is Sony… they are making some pritty bad ass cameras!

    1. “By far the biggest threat to m4/3 is Sony… they are making some pritty bad ass cameras!”..they are also making some really dumb lenses. Its bizarre…with all the potential of the new NEX-7 body….Even the new Zeiss-branded lens for NEX (I am a fan..I have a Zeiss MF 21mm for my full frame Canon… awesome glass)..is so clunky it can’t get out of its own way. Sony has a lot of holes in their shoe from continuously shooting themselves in the foot, no? 🙂

      1. Agreed the lenses are not so small – but they still are making a very competative and capable system… Sony may be more a threat to FF then to m4/3 due to lens size?? But still I would not be supprized if they tryed to make a X type lens in the future, making the sony waaay more portable than it is currently!

        1. What I don’t understand is with all of Sony’s capital…why aren’t there any truly pro lenses. The whole point of mirrorless in my world is to make powerful cameras in a small package. I drool at the specs of the NEX7 body…but just walk away at the autofocus lens selection. I would rather shoot with my 5D Mark II and all the incredible L glass. When I can put an extremely sharp 85mm f/1.2 in front of a full frame sensor with autofocus (albeit slow).. I can live with the size. And hey…I can get a damn good mini version with an MFT body and the new Leica branded 25mm or the Oly 45 f/1.8 in an extremely portable package… I guess if you are a manual focus, Leica glass guy the Sony has some allure but not for my style of shooting.
          It’s great that there is so much to choose from these days…really exciting!

          1. Jim….I think that MFT is a GREAT little photographers tool all on its own….but I love the way it complements an existing DSLR system. I just ran out of the house to do a window estimate for a couple in their summer home (I am a freelance carpenter..its all me..LOL!). They have a wall where they want a new window that will look out at the ocean. I grabbed my MFT bag took pics and actually will suggest a beautiful oval window for the space. I can drop it into their room in photoshop so that they can see just how it will look. MFT is all I need. 7-14 served me well. Who do you think will get the job!!!!! Digital lets me do artwork and serves as a work tool for me.
            I just sold a print in a gallery yesterday, but that was shot with my DSLR. GREAT PRINTS from those files!!! (although I have printed and sold MFT images in galleries as well).
            I love both formats and MFT just keeps getting better and better.

      2. If they had put the pretty bad ass sensor (NEX-5N) on the pretty bad ass camera (NEX-7) I might have given the system a thought, but the lens ecosystem doesn’t have 1/5 the drive of m43…

      3. The NEX-7 + Zeiss 24/1.8 is actually an awesome combination and something m4/3 should learn from. The excellent built-in EVF, 24mp low-noise high DR sensor, and fast 36mm equivalent prime is something that would be very welcome in the m4/3 world (don’t need 24mp, but 12-16mp with low noise and high DR like Sony sensors have would be great).

        Apparently, the EVF is even better than Oly’s VF-2, and m4/3 doesn’t have a premium, super-fast 35-mm equivalent. The 20/1.7 is the closest thing, but its AF is slow and noisy, and it would need to be f/1.4 to match the Zeiss in equivalent DoF control given the crop factor difference.

        Yes, i know m4/3 has the 25/1.4, but sometimes you want a fast 35mm equivalent prime. I love my 35/1.4G on FF. You can take stunning environmental portraits with it.

        1. Well, if you’re going to go for something as big as that Zeiss 1.4 you might as well stick a Panaleica 25mm/1.4 fourthirds on a Panasonic G3. I thought the entire point of mirrorless cameras are high quality, DSLR-like images but with smaller lenses? If you’re going to go out with a Nex + Zeiss, you might as well get a Pentax K5 with pancake – it will protrude and weigh far less.

  10. @Jim
    anything over 10fps is absolute overkill and will make for some lazy “photography”, in real world use 4-6 frames per second covers 99% of everything…
    a built in ND grad filter would lose the need for 1/16000 except for absolute specialist scenarios

    *just my thoughts*

    1. Yep would love a built in 3 stage ND filter – absolutly…

      But would also love 1/100,000 shutter – (flash sync-able)… only electronic shutter will have such potential! – the more the merryier!

      I agree 10fps is the spray and pray – but if you are gonna pray why not pray to a 1000fps god 😉

      I see cameras as imaging machines – they need to do anything you might possibly ask – I would love control from USB and to be able to reprogram the camera or download apps for it – timelaps, movement detection, audio trigger, face trigger – whatever just dont hold back when the technology can deliver all this with ease!

      1. Not sure why you need an ND filter on the Nikon 1. Both models have shutters to 1/16,000 of a second, which should be enough to max out their lenses in bright light.

        1. So I can drag my shutter when doing daytime timelaps shots – like I said I need a camera to be flexable not designed spacificly for 1 job… m4/3 has that potential!

          N.B. if I could take images of sunspots with my cam (with built in NDs) that would be a bonus, I like astoronomy – currently that is beyond any ND filters ability though!

          P.S. just as a side note having looked on IR, I reckon the Nikom J1 has a 1 stop (maybe 1.5stop) ISO advantage on the PENs!! – although I feel the lenses for the J1 are not at all good currently.

  11. First i look this size comparision, then i look back in the analog days and i see contax T3, ricoh GR1 and minox 35 GT, or even leica CL. M43 and sigma DP was the first hope of having high IQ compact cameras that could compete with high end SLR.

    But then nikon and pentax released that small sensor system camera, when Panasonic is more intersted in releasing more crappy slow zoom kit lens with super slimmy body with less direct control but more stupid touch&easy gimmicks.

    What is the real interest of these cameraq against a, for example, compact like fuji X10 that cover mostly every usefull focal for an every day camera, have a small sensor, but a fast zoom, the same dof control than a 14-42 m43 kit lens (but two stop faster !), a not so bad OVF in a smaller package with better direct controls ?

    Please, camera manufacturer, i don’t want a mirrorless vs high end small sensor compact dilemna, i want a poor man leica.

    Please help me saying goodbye to my good ol’ contax T2.

    1. Seb… Contax made the poor man’s Leica…with autofocus…it was the G2 buddy…not the T2 (T2 was a 35mm film point & shoot)… The G2 was/is Fantastic film camera….it had it all.
      The Fuji x10 lens sounds great!!!! but the sensor is waaaaaaaaaaaaay too small…AND you can count on all of the quirky traits (and a long list of work-arounds posted on the net) of the x100 no doubt.
      Right now…MFT (still the GF1 for me) is still the closest thing to a poor-mans-Leica in my book. Maybe the Pany GF7 body will put it right in you lap?

  12. I can understand if you don’t like the lenses. But as far as E-PM1 Vs. 1-J1, just look at how much more elegant and less intimidating the 1-J1 looks. And it is smaller too! It focuses faster, has higher frame rate and better video. Ever since yesterday, the E-PM1 seems to be lacking a “best shot” feature and the “video+snapshot” mode.

    Nikon 1-V1 Vs. E-P3 is a whole other matter. As far as systems go, micro 4/3 is certainly far better ATM. Far far better. But sorry, the 1-J1 beats the E-PM1 as a camera body.

    1. +1 on the J1 vs E-PM1. J1 (and V1) copy the top plate shape of the Leica X1, not a bad thing IMHOP, and overall the J1 has a simpler and more attractive body than the plasticky E-PM1. It also includes a built-in flash and full size LCD (shame on you Oly for a 2.4″ usable area LCD).

      The Admin’s comparison photo has the J1 hovering a good 1/2″ above the E-PM1; had they been aligned at back-of camera it would be clear the J1 + 10-30 kit is appreciably more compact than the E-PM1. Put the wide angle on it, and the J1 is compact and attractive by any standard.

      Based on photos posted to date, it appears the J1 is getting more out of its sensor at high ISO’s as well. This is a wake up call to Pan/Oly, negating the excuse that smaller sensors can’t come closer to larger using newer technologies. Oly needs a new sensor source and fast.

      Regarding noise at low ISO’s as the trade-off (DPR forum), the G3 has the same issue. Not an excuse, just the way it is.

      Future lens prototypes shown by Nikon also seem to indicate a commitment to this platform. Yes, they’re too big and clunky, but this may change. mFT’s had 3 years to evolve; we’ll see where this goes.

      Things could have been much worse for Pan/Oly had Nikon gone with a sensor closer in size to mFT and priced it more aggressively. But they need to get off the dime with a class-leading sensor, focus peaking, full size LCD, built-in flash, etc. in their consumer (E-PMx) model, and a built-in EVF in a compact rangefinder-style body at the G3’s price point.

      1. Admin’s shot is the E-PL3 not the E-PM1. Wait til you see the E-PM1 with the new Panasonic PZ 14-42 on it. Then wait till you see some decent comparison shots for the Oly vs Nikon. I’ll bet you won’t think the Nikon is a wake-up call for m43. After all, the only step Nikon has really taken with this camera is a better processor.

  13. Regular bashing is related to personal insecurity that Nikon overnight made investment in M4/3 less valuable.
    I can only welcome Nikon’s innovations!
    Electronics features of new cameras is way forward for mirrorless.
    I shocked to see that Pana after 3 years on this market does not have answer to this.

    1. StevO,

      “Things could have been much worse for Pan/Oly had Nikon gone with a sensor closer in size to mFT and priced it more aggressively.”

      I disagree. I think this is the worst possible scenario for micro 4/3. It looks to me that Nikon is aiming for the classic pincer movement [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pincer_movement]. You can certainly expect Nikon to come out with a mirrorless full frame FX size system within the next four years. Then micro 4/3 will be squeezed from the bottom by Nikon 1 and from the top by a new mirrorless system for pros with a much larger sensor and F mount compatibility.

      1. I don’t think that’s necessarily a bad thing either. A FF mirrorless body and lenses would both be large and heavy and the price certainly steep. It would find buyers, but I don’t think many among the mFT crowd. And the 1 series will always be hobbled by the 50% smaller sensor (a greater disparity then between mFT and APS-C) in terms of DOF control and noise, a compromise Nikon intentionally accepted so as not to cannibalize their DSLR sales.

        mFT is about balance, a small sacrifice in IQ with payback in affordable small/light bodies and lenses which have now been realized. I think ultimately it is the right place to be. But, the J1 does point in a positive direction in a number of regards, and Olympus really now needs a class-leading sensor more than ever.

      2. @beuler
        “Nikon to come out with a mirrorless full frame FX size system within the next four years” omg listen to yourself Nikon brings out a mirrorless in 2015 to attack micro four thirds from the top!

        by 2015 micro four thirds
        af100 will be on it’s 3rd iteration
        gh6 will also be out
        gfx4 will be out
        ep7’s will be out various models
        ep pro version 4 (various models)
        g7 various models
        probably another 2-3 camera manufacturers will have joined (seen sense)

        let alone micro four thirds phones, go pro equivalents, red scarlet equivalents,polaroid equivalents, lots of third party lenses and accessories, apps…all at reasonable prices 😀

        micro four thirds won’t be standing still and will make the right/useful/wanted developments for photographers and videographers of all kinds

        ###households (and workplaces) will be sharing micro four thirds lenses and accessories in 2015 just like they share mobile phone chargers now###

    1. You are talking about a lot of R&D money being spent in 4 years on a marginal slice of the market (I hope they do not churn a new iteration out every year for no apperent reason). But I really hope your fantasy comes true. You assume Cannon and Nikon will not spend much more to squeeze the m43 market share. You also don’t know who Nikon was aiming for, neither did I. It is not the people who write in blog forums. As it pains, me my wife saw the picture of the pink 1 J1 and wanted one. I have the kit with two lenses on preorder (it is her 25th wedding aniversery present). Even though that is the 3rd different camera system I will have to deal with at least I will not have to show her how to use my camera every time she wants to use it to get a higher quality picture than her point and shoot (with the 1 J1 all she has to do is set what scene she wants once, zoom and shoot). I bet that damm pink camera will sell out (I thought it was the stupidest thing ever when I first saw it). :-!
      Bash Away!

  14. I repeat my prediction – if the image quality is OK (much better than point and shoots), Nikon 1 will outsell m4/3 by a large margin. And many of the new features will find their way to Nikon’s DSLRs, most of which will become mirrorless but using F-mount lenses.

    1. “I repeat my prediction – if the image quality is OK (much better than point and shoots),” that’s one huge if given current IQ of the XZ-1, LX5 and S100…

      “Nikon 1 will outsell m4/3 by a large margin.” Nikon certainly has the advantage of brand recognition and placement/proper displays in big box retailers like BB, but a combination of high intro pricing (which could change by the holidays), low MP sensor (even though it makes sense) and small lens selection compared to the latest mFT’s will undercut their advantage. At an entry price of $650 I think most consumers will research their purchase online which will reveal its shortcomings, but I’ve been wrong before.

      What it will assuredly do is get Pan/Oly to drop their prices before the holidays, especially so on the over-priced (my opinion) $700 E-PL3 and $900 E-P3. I’ll wager $500 and $700 respectively, with the E-PM1 at $400.

      “And many of the new features will find their way to Nikon’s DSLRs, most of which will become mirrorless but using F-mount lenses.”

      +1 on this.

        1. “Olympus phased out 4/3 DSLRs too soon.”

          Totally. All they need is a better sensor (not that the E-5 has a bad sensor, but the industry has moved on… everyone else is a generation ahead in sensor tech), and they’re very competitive.

          1. +1 as well. Still happily using my E-620, E-510 and some excellent FT lenses. Love Truepic colors and IBIS, only a great new sensor is lacking.

  15. Many people seem to be assuming that Nikon chose to use the smaller sensor, as if it was a plan to rival m43 but not NEX.
    What if Nikon really wanted to make a higher quality camera with an APS-C sensor, but Sony would not supply them the 24MP sensor used in the NEX? Unless Nikon could get a sensor to rival that in the NEX-7 they would be at a disadvantage, marketing clout or not.
    That is pure speculation, but it will be interesting to see the slrs Nikon comes up with now that the three Sony cameras with the 24MP sensor are becoming available. Will Nikon get the new sensor or be forced to wait?
    Regarding the Nikon 1 system, all I can see is an initial release consisting of lenses which all sit in the 28-300mm equivalent focal length range covered by many compacts. When I was using a 28-200mm digital superzoom the principal thing that made me want to upgrade was that I wanted a superwide lens. The Pentax Q system at least has a low cost fisheye lens to provide something different.
    I suspect Nikon has seen that some people with Nikon dslrs are buying an m43 or NEX as a small second camera and is targeting those people.
    Unless a more comprehensive range of lenses is made available, the appeal of the system will remain limited.

    1. “What if Nikon really wanted to make a higher quality camera with an APS-C sensor, but Sony would not supply them the 24MP sensor used in the NEX? […] it will be interesting to see the slrs Nikon comes up with now that the three Sony cameras with the 24MP sensor are becoming available. Will Nikon get the new sensor or be forced to wait?”

      This is a very good point, MP Burke. I think this is why you’ll continue to see more Nikon designed (or at least made by someone other than Sony) sensors like the one in the D3100 and the 1-series.

      Nikon recognizes that their dependence on Sony Semiconductor as the single supplier of the most important component of their cameras is risky… and they’re doing something about it as Sony is becoming more of a player in the market.

  16. I think what really undercuts Nikon’s advantage is Panasonic’s new X14-42 pancake zoom. With it, the overall kit weight of the GF3 (359g) is lower than the Nikon J1 with the 10-30mm zoom(392g) despite the Lumix having twice the sensor area. You won’t buy the J1 to get a more compact kit.

  17. Nikon J1 studio test images are up on Imaging Resource if you guys are interested. I just had a look and compared to E-P3. Is it just me or does the Nikon perform badly at low ISO 200, 400? The E-P3 is alot cleaner. At 1600 the E-P3 is still better but not by as much. I am quite disappointed with the low ISO performance of the Nikon sensor. I was hoping for better. I also compared to XZ-1 and I think at low ISO the Nikon only just beats it. I was just looking at JPEgs and trying to compare images with similar level of Noise Reduction – I know this can be difficult.

    Have a look for yourself

    http://www.imaging-resource.com/PRODS/NIKONJ1/NIKONJ1A.HTM

    see Samples

    1. This sentiment that something has gone horribly wrong with the V1 sensor at low ISO has been expressed in many of the initial comparisons.

      Nikon is potentially sitting on a powder keg.

      Their new camera actually performs WORSE than P&Ss at low ISO.

  18. “anything over 10fps is absolute overkill and will make for some lazy “photography””

    Hogan doesn’t know what he isn’t talking about.

    The average consumer isn’t interested in even 10fps. Do you realize the work load required to analyze that many images? And “intelligent” software that automatically selects the right ones, isn’t the answer. Software for making judgement calls on which images you like will never exist.

    There are many times I regret holding down the button on my E-PL1 to take 3fps, and I usually have the patience to wade through those images.

    .0001% of the market is interested in looking at a golf swing at 150 fps.

    1. Nikon has dealt with the “workflow” issue in two ways, actually. SPS pulls 5 out of 20 images based upon some quality assessment issue. The Smart Photo version matches one shot with a one-second (60 frame) quasi-video in some sort of Harry Potter like image. The camera also starts recording prior to pressing the shutter release, by the way, so you can be “slow to react.”

      But you are correct. Overall, the thing that camera companies get wrong the most is workflow. Taking a lot of shots is a big chore. The camera makers aren’t making it any easier by pushing pixels and frame rates.

      1. @Thom Hogan
        what consumers will end up with is images that will quickly look the same (when you got you fake smile face on) over a period of time, the Nikon 1 could refuse to take or process photos when you look zany/weird/terrible or accidentally/on purpose chop/crop part of a face or when you look good/funny with your eyes closed or not smiling, which is quite popular at the moment (even I get fed up when I’m smiling in a photo).
        To be honest I think the target market Nikon is after with the Nikon 1 would prioritize upgrading their smart phone (iphone 5, galaxy note etc) where they can social media upload instantly over purchasing these cameras at the price being asked.
        Also the curves are wrong, even the shade of available pink is wrong, it’s too garish and the female target market would want an auto pop up flash.

        Anyways….

  19. I think Nikon had already missed the moment to releasing their mirrorles system. Nikon just following the “trend just like sony and samsung with their own concept and smaller size sensor . and I I don’t think it will success like their FF/aps-c camera. M/43 had already mature sony and samsung is getting better and of course the advantage of their aps-c size sensor.
    all i want to say GOOD LUCK NIKON’,..I wished you did these 4 years ago . or just jump unto M4/3 system.

      1. Samsung has some very nice primes in its system and on its roadmap.

        What they are missing are a competitive sensor and wide angle lenses (seriously, Samsung, where are they???).

  20. Thom makes a good point about megapixels. A lot of people (myself included) carry their EVIL camera around on excursions and vacations because they are much more portable than DSLRs. We don’t want a zillion 24 MP RAW files clogging up our SD cards or our laptops on vacation (and we don’t have time to lightbox and discard the duds when we’re on vacation – we have better things to do).

    Call me a grognard, but I’m perfectly happy with the 12 MP on my GF1, and it’s a shame development on the photon sites for the sensor has stopped (as opposed to AF development by Oly).

    I hope Panasonic gets that a lot of us don’t want a 24MP monstrosity but still appreciate a well-built and well-handling body with the GFX1. Although being their flagship RF-style m43 camera, it’ll probably end up having at least 16 MP.

    1. Sometime at the beginning of the year there was a rumor that Pana was working on a new 14 MP sensor. So maybe they have this still in the pipeline as a flagship stills sensor, or the GFX1 gets a multiaspect sensor like GH2 (and likely GH3), hopefully new or definitely improved from the GH2. And the lower models may use the 16MP sensor from the G3 for 1 or 1 1/2 years.

  21. I would like to have many (24) mpixels for acouple of reasons – but then I also need to invest in >2000Euro lenses to utilize the full potential of the sensor. A NEX7 with NEX lenses is a silly combination, it has to be Zeiss or similar.
    The Nikon 1 system is tempting only for Nikonistas that only cares about brand. One of smaller m4/3 is a better and cheaper alternative. The Nikon 1 competes with Fuji X10 more than with m4/3.
    The m4/3 now needs flagships models with better sensors (the weak point of m4/3)and continue development of attractive lenses for both “casuals” and “enthusiasts” like me,

    1. 24 MP systems definitely have a place (see D3X). But generally not for consumer products. Heck, the D3S is still only 12 MP, fer chrissake!

    2. My biggest problem with 24 mega pixels would be storage (& redundant backup) and also processing. I would need to invest in some serious hardware. Especially if I wanted to edit/post-process on the road, I needed a new and much stronger notebook.

      For what I do, 12MP is totally enough and manageable.

      1. Well, that is easily solved: the hardware needed to handle that amount of data costs a fraction of the camera + lenses. If you can efford a Nex7 + good lenses (?) or better an alpha 77 with good lenses, with a third of the money needed you can buy a new macbook pro and a couple of 1+tb external hardrives.

  22. Who in the world wants and needs a *system camera* with social functions? Sorry, Thom Hogan, but the industry has to get first some basics right: battery life. It is still way too poor in reality with almost all mirrorless systems.

    In my opinion, this social stuff would be completely superfluous in a system camera, and therefore a waste of development efforts.

      1. What was that? Is YouDidn’tDidYou agreeing with me? ;~) Did I miss the world apocalypse? ;~)

        @mahler has a point: we need power efficiency and bigger batteries. (Oh lord I know how Apple’s camera would be: no removable battery and most of the air pockets inside the case filled with lithium.) Basically a 200-shot-per-charge camera is not an all day camera and isn’t going to deal with constant GPS and WiFi/4G/whatever being added. We’re about half the power capability that we really need, plus half the efficiency (i.e., we need a 4x improvement).

        Still, digital cameras are one of the most Internet unfriendly digital devices remaining, and it’s the camera makers fault. The low end cameras are especially vulnerable to the Apples, Facebooks, and even Samsungs of the world, who won’t make the same mistakes. Thing is, imaging sensors are now nearly ubiquitous and commodity like up to the 1/1.7″ size. There’s very little barrier to entry left, and we’ve got one giant imaging/camera patent pool on the market right now (Kodak’s).

        @YouDidn’tDidYou is correct: the demand for connection goes high into the camera user community, not just down at the casual user level. The demand is not being served.

  23. Let’s be real guys. I love me some m4/3 and still I shoot mostly with an Olympus E30. The Nikon system will out sell m4/3 20 to 1. They got one big hurdle out of the way, better sensor and processor tech. Even with a stop less light gathering, the high ISO files look pretty good. Nikon got the tech on the insides down. Sony with the N7 has the muscle and EVF down. Oly & Pana have a great set of lenses. Oly has that handsome EP3 body. Pana has got video down. Now if we could some how get all these things in one system m4/3 could be an actual option besides APS-C dslrs.

  24. If and when Nikon decides to build something for our market level (( high end mirrorless) all they have to do is bring back the 35 Ti with an APSC sensor and they will be in the game. Who knows, maybe they are working on it right now….

  25. If and when Nikon decides to build something for our market level ( high end mirrorless) all they have to do is bring back the 35 Ti with an APSC sensor and they will be in the game. Who knows, maybe they are working on it right now….

  26. Something everyone missed is that the Nikon 1″ sensor is exactly the same size as of a 16mm film camera, so they can use all those 16mm lenses without vignetting. So covertly they are going after the video market. There isheir madness.

    This is coming from an OM-4, E-510 and E-P1 user!! some sense in t

  27. Something everyone missed is that the Nikon 1″ sensor is exactly the same size as of a 16mm film camera, so they can use all those 16mm lenses without vignetting. So covertly they are going after the video market. There is some sense in their madness.

    This is coming from an OM-4, E-510 and E-P1 user!!

  28. Same size as an m4/3 but with a whole lot smaller sensor (haven’t the Canon-Nikon lot been laughing at 4/3 and m4/3 shooters for precisely that? So now suddenly small size is okay if it is good enough? Nyeh). AND a lot costlier to boot. Says it all, really. One can only wonder what Nikon is smoking.

    But maybe Nikon must know a lot of well-heeled soccer mums who have large handbags or are willing to lug bigger gear than their compacts for not much more improvement in absolute picture quality.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search

Search
Advertisement
SNAPCLOUDBack up everyphotoTry freeSample ad

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

*Please also check your spam folder if you don't get the confirmation mail. And mark the mail as "non-spam" to see the future newsletter.

Advertisement
SNAPCLOUDBack up everyphotoTry freeSample ad
Advertisement
GRIPLINEPro camerastraps &bagsDiscoverSample ad
Advertisement
PHOTOGEARUp to30% offcamerasSee dealsSample ad