Advertisement
SNAPCLOUDBack up every photoUnlimited RAW storage, 30 days freeTry freeSample ad
Advertisement
Advertisement

(part 1) Back from Australia-China: unfair E-P1 versus Mamiya7 comparison.

Dear readers!

I am finally back from my journey. I had a job to do in Australia and China. First of all I would like to thank all Australian and Chinese people I met during those two months. The whole trip was an incredible experience and I never had any difficulty at all working in both countries. People were extremely friendly and I came back to Europe with many many many good memories. Thanks!

My work:

I made one documentary and three photoreportages. In the next days I will show you some of the photos I made. As you may remember I had the Mamiya 7 and the Olympus with me. The first story was on request of a European newspaper. I’ll show you a comparison of the results from both cameras. It is obvious that this is an unfair comparison because the Mamiya gives you a 6×7 cm positive image! But maybe some of you are interested to see how big the difference is. Please notice that I am very very very happy with the E-P1 performance which is easily on par (and sometimes beats) the quality of other (non fullframe) DSLR! And please notice that this isn’t meant to be a über-professional comparison. To do that you need a resolution chart, both lenses with the same aperture, a tripod, same light and other limits like that. So give me a break! I do not pretend to be a professional reviewer 🙂

The photo shows you a 60 year old miner in Lightning Ridge (Australia). I always took one photo with the mamiya (6×7 positive film) and one with the Olympus (in RAW). The positive film has been scanned at 3200 dpi with the flextight professional drumscanner (16bit, tiff format, gives me a 60Megapixel resolution photo which weighs 320 MegaByte!!!)

The first photo you see has been taken with the Olympus E-P1 and 17mm lens (Raw converted in jpg with Photoshop and downsized).

e-p1_vitt

The Mamiya 7 photo (mamiya 65mm lens, fuji velvia 100, downsized):

mamiya7_vitt

The 65mm mamiya lens is the equivalent of 32mm in 35mm format.

I cropped and downsized both pictures:

e-p1_vitt_crop

mamiya7_vitt_crop

The difference in sharpness is huge. The E-P1 performs well but nothing beats medium format film.

Next photo, very difficult situation. Only one strong light!

First the E-P1 and 17mm lens (Raw converted in jpg with Photoshop and downsized)…

e-p1_tunnel

….and the mamiya 7 (mamiya 65mm lens, fuji velvia 100, downsized)

mamiya7_tunnel

As you see there is a difference in white balance.  I haven’t made a white balance on the mamiya photo. I used a film for natural light where there was artificial light (I had no other film with me).

Now I am going to show you the a crop from the head and this time in real size…no downsizing!!!

e-p1_tunnel_cropmamiya7_tunnel_crop

The E-P1 is overexposed and burns part of the head. My fault! With the spot metering inside the mamiya7 I measured the head of the man and this saved the photo.

Finally I am going to tell a little more about his story. His name is Vittorio. Since 1969 he lives in the middle of the australian nowhere. He owns a mine. And on top of the mine he has built a castle!

You can enter the mine from his living room…(photo taken with the E-P1)

e-p1

and believe me…he really has built a castle (taken with mamiya7)!!!

castle

I will post more pictures and comparisons in the next days…

cheers

Alejandro

Share this story
Community

Join the discussion

8 Responses

  1. I’m an Aussie and I’m proud that you explore some of the country which is a little different from the touristy places like Sydney, etc. Thanks for the pictures and the descriptions. 🙂

  2. This post is so long that it’s really difficult to look at the site on mobile phone. Would you please change this entry so that on the home page there is only a short preview and to view all the pictures you have to click on the post.

    Thanks

  3. I spent two years reviewing medium format cameras. I was sure I wanted a Bronica or a nice working Rollei, however all my research kept pointing me towards this hideous plastic beast called the Mamiya 7. I have had my Mamiya 7 now for over 5 years with no complaints, no regrets, and I am still amazed by the detail and quality. I love the focusing, the shutter, the lenses, everything but the plastic housing (mine is thoroughly wrapped in duct and electrical tape to ward off breakage and potential muggers). In my very amateur opinion, I feel there is no finer camera on the planet and it is a wonderful weapon to fight off the brainless zombie hordes who seriously believe digital looks good. Film #1. (nice photos, thanks for all the hard work)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search

Search
Advertisement
SNAPCLOUDBack up everyphotoTry freeSample ad

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

*Please also check your spam folder if you don't get the confirmation mail. And mark the mail as "non-spam" to see the future newsletter.

Advertisement
SNAPCLOUDBack up everyphotoTry freeSample ad
Advertisement
GRIPLINEPro camerastraps &bagsDiscoverSample ad
Advertisement
PHOTOGEARUp to30% offcamerasSee dealsSample ad