photozone just published their full review and says that you buy Magic for the extra Money. Here an excerpt from their conclusions:
“So is the Fujinon XF 56mm f/1.2 R APD the magician that it is supposed to be ? Well, mostly. I reckon the sample images showed you that the bokeh is mostly as smooth as silk except in really difficult scenes (where most conventional lenses would fail as well).
Now is it worth it? Well, of course, it is! How often can you buy magic for money after all! We’d also favour it over the already great non-APD variant. Therefore highly recommended“”