ice skating shot with gh2 + panasonic lumix g x 45-175mm from Roderick Kar on Vimeo.
The Japanese website DSLR-check (Click here) posted a set of image comparisons between the [shoplink 25104]14-42mm pancake X zoom[/shoplink] and other lenses. What’s really interesting with the test is that he used the lens on both Panasonic and Olympus camera. As you know Panasonic has a lens correction while the Olympus has not. You really can see the difference! At first glance I wouldn’t recommend that lens for the use on an Olympus camera if you shot JPEG’s only. Otherwise the lens performs very well on the Panasonic cameras! And keep in mind how tiny that zoom lens is, that makes the image quality of the lens look even more impressive!
You can click these links to search for 14-42mm X lens preorders: [shopcountry 25104]
The Panasonic 45-175mm X lens is in Stock in some stores. Check at [shopcountry 25103].
52 Responses
My following comment is in general and not specifically towards this lens. I am not interested in lenses that require software correction. It’s a road to obsolescence of the lens. I also am a predominantly RAW shooter and I neither want to be tied to OEM software for correction, nor do I want to have to purchase correction software (which also has inbuilt obsolescence).
As far as the new 14-42 goes, how many times have Oly and Panasonic already peddled do-overs of this standard zoom? If at least they’d made it a 12-40!
Eye,
Your comments make no sense. The software to correct lenses is about as likely to vanish as abandonware or 8-bit platform games. Guess what? They are all still easily found. It is the progression of camera technology not the regression of it to have software correction. I would be elated if somehow magically perfect lenses in every way could be optical but that magic beast doesn’t exist and if you could make such a lens, it would cost you thousands and thousands of dollars. You can’t have it all without some trade-off.
H,
Thanks for pointing out my nonsensical view. Don’t forget to inform Leica that optically corrected lenses are a folly.
Glad you like 8-bit platform games. I myself still like Fate of Atlantis and the original Monkey Island series. Not that easy to get to work on my current system. 😉
What you call progression of camera technology, I call a cheap shortcut. I am not asking for magically perfect lenses, but for lenses that are optically corrected to the point I can use that lens without having to resort to digital help.
A 14-42 mm lens is not an overly complicated optical design. Admittedly, miniaturization may compromise the design, especially in such a small lens. Then again, I don’t care if a lens is tiny or not.
Not sure why you think I asked to get anything without a tradeoff. If anything, I find a system with optically compromised lenses makes no sense. I’d rather pay more and carry more weight. It’s just fine by me if you are happy with cheapness.
„Don’t forget to inform Leica that optically corrected lenses are a folly.”
Sorry, but the way Leica stands for is everything but worth to follow. At the price tag you can buy Leica bodies/lenses you’ll always find anything much better in every aspects from other manufacturers.
I’m pretty courious how long will resist Leica just by “abusing” of their brand’s shiny reputation.
Sorry, but Leica has optical and build quality second to none. That also explains the high price as cost increases exponentially with optical improvement. Leica is sitting at a level of optical quality that is simply not expedient for other manufacturers.
But the Leica M9 full frame has no better IQ than a €600 G3, for which you can also get excellent Leica lenses (25mm, 45mm) and non-Leica lenses (12mm, 20mm, Olympus 45mm, and some excellent zooms such as 7-14mm).
Of course, the build quality is different, but there are other advantages to the m43 setup as well.
The Leica rangefinder is really a niche photographic solution that will never satisfy more than a small percentage of all photographers. Leica themselves acknowledge that de facto: they released the X1, and announced that they will make a new mirrorless system.
I sincerely doubt that a G3 with the 25mm summilux will produce the same image quality as an M9 with 50mm summilux. But then again, I’m not a pixel peeper.
Agreed. I’m not a pixel peeper either, but I can see a fundamental difference between those 2 lenses. I don’t know what it is, but it seems like the magic resides on Bokeh.
I did a comparison with the DPR studio shots recently and was surprised that there is very little difference between a G3 and M9. If anything, the G3 has an advantage in the higher ISO regions (M9 only goes up to ISO2500 for a reason…). At lower ISOs the M9 might edge it.
Of course, this does not take into account the aesthetic aspects of Bokeh rendition and DOF. A 25mm f/1.4 on a G3 will not render the same as a 50mm f/1.1 on an M9. But technically, there’s very little difference in the output.
This lens maybe overly complicated, but it actually even better than very simple 20mm /1.7 when f4.5 in this test. Did you really check those images?
I think you are just head tripping. Before head trip, use your eyes and look at the pictures!
I find this statement an impossibility. Full frame will always have a technical difference with reference to a smaller sensor. Also the m4/3 sensors have 1/4 the area of full frame and compare poorly even with aps sensors (generally a year+ behind in tech).
This is wishful thinking at best.
I would be interested in getting this lens (14-42) because it is such a nice pancake, but I agree that software correction is undesirable. Especially if Panasonic try to market the lens as a higher end model.
I think maybe m4/3 is splitting up a bit with zooms like this for the general consumer market, while the primes are going more towards the the enthusiast market.
That might be good. I could see myself using a high end m4/3 body (a GF “pro”) with high end primes like the PanaLeica 25mm.
Sorry to rain on your parade, but Leica also uses software correction. Try to use both an encoded and non-encoded lens on an M9, and you’ll see the difference!
It’s all about the results. How to get there is not that important.
I wonder what makes you so sure that ‘optical is always better than digital’.
Optical is the first step. Optical is the key step. Photography is all about optics.
Just about many of the photographic greats spend a hedious amount of time in the darkroom improving their pictures. To say photography is all about optics is plain ridiculous.
How much can there be done in the darkroom if the optics are no good?
Oh Really? I could have sworn that many of the great photographs of early 20th century by say Henri Cartier-Bresson were done with inferior optics to the present, yet they are remembered because they captured a moment, or had some meaning. Bitching left right center about this and that is simply distraction from taking good photos. What’s even more hilarious is that these days, Nikon, Canon etc. are all incorporating some manner of software correction in their cameras. Even Leica has software correction in the M9. What else do you want to complain about?
I said that photography is all about optics as a response to the question why optical correction is always better than digital.
To start in a darkroom (or digital PP) with a great negative (or RAW file) because the lens was high quality, allows for a better end result and/or more room for manipulation.
Whatever else you make of it is up to you.
Digital photography is the sum of optics, electronic and processing. You can’t see the photo if you miss one element, right?
Now there is a choice: designers can consider each elements as a “step”, and sum the inefficiences of each one, or they can consider all the elements as one system, and optimize it at the best, letting each element doing what it does better.
It might be an optical shortcut, but it’s a shortcut that gets you better IQ in a smaller lens package. Most of us are using M43 because we want small cameras, so it’s a reasonable trade-off to make on a system such as this.
On the other hand, I wouldn’t be likely to take a 20% smaller 85/1.2 no my Canon setup for the trade off of software-corrected edge distortion.
But that’s just me. Obviously everyone is different, or nobody would be carrying enormous NEX lenses. 🙂
The fact that the lens is pancake-sized and features power zoom make it substantially different than the prior zooms. I agree that the old 14-42mm didn’t have much purpose (other than to cut manufacturing costs,) but this new lens clearly has its own value, whether it would be personally useful to you or not.
Just because they use software correction doesn’t mean they’re especially flawed optically, by the way.
Software-corrected lenses are a pathetic compromise. Completely agree with Eye!
All lenses are a compromise, its just stupid stubbornes not too use the tools available to give the best result for a given set of specifications.
Software-corrected sensor data is a pathetic compromise. Give me my image data as unprocessed 1’s and 0’s so I can gaze upon my eighty million bits and marvel at its numeric significance! 😛
Like I said earlier, so long as a nice picture comes out the other end, who cares? What is the goal here? Photography or gear worship? This obsession with perfect optical formulas reminds me of car racing, where (say) the Porsche guys might get smoked by an Evo or something, and rationalize it by saying “but that’s not a REAL sports car”.
Fast is fast, and good is good. It doesn’t matter how you get there, it’s all about the final result.
Software correction is a part of the main concept of M43. M43 can’t be possible without software correction, or lens will be much larger. It’s fine that you against software correction, but it does mean M43 is not your camera. You should buy M9.
I remember that heard the same kind of comment when DIGITAL CAMERA has started appear on the market, and a lot of people hated digital camera.
I agree with you about too many 14mm zoom, I’m waiting for compact 12mm zoom.
Concept of m4/3 is removing analog film era mirror/all that bulky stuff what’s needed for optical viewfinder.
Without that wide angles wouldn’t be much any smaller than in 4/3 regardless of software corrections:
With mirror no longer in the way of things flange back distance can be made more balanced with the sensor size (NEX has too small distance for APS-C sensor causing problems with oblique light rays) allowing more freedom in optical design of wide angle lenses with lesser degree of retrofocus design. That’s why rangefinders have long had very compact wide angles.
But for longer focal length lenses neither that or software corrections can do much anything because f-ratio binds their absolute minimum front element diameter to focal length and you can’t just have arbitrary number of barrels to make lens retract into smaller space than previously.
Just do comparison of same aperture wide and tele zooms of 4/3 (E-system) and m4/3. The longer the focal length lens covers the less there’s size difference.
As far as I know the m43 standard means that every lens has corrections built in and can communicate those to any m43camera. Perhaps the Olympus cameras are just a firmware upgrade away from having the proper corrections for these lenses, or perhaps they are giving up on this part of the standard. anyone know?
Any idea if those inbuilt lens corrections ( “pixels stretcher/squeezer and FOV cropper” :p ) affect the RAW or only the JPG image?
It does affect the RAW image – more precisely, the information is bounded in RAW file as hint, but if your firm belief doesn’t let you enjoy this information, you may ignore it ad libitum. 😛
Yeah, it affects the RAW – and when you convert that RAW into B&W all that stretching and squeezing is revealed in its glorious mush.
That “stretching and squeezing” occurs in optically corrected lenses too. Both routes degrade the image. From decades of using optically corrected lenses, we know it’s always the corners that exhibit the worst quality – maybe it’s time to take a different approach to solving this?
> maybe it’s time to take a different approach to solving this?
So why don’t you start by getting facts straight!
Corrections done before light gets to sensor are lossless unless designers screwed it up and optical design worsens some other aberration:
Optical corrections are just keeping light rays going the way as they should for forming best possible image.
But anything you do after the image is captured by sensor is lossy. It’s like drawing/printing image to some rubber sheet and then grapping from one corner and stretching that sheet.
And those corners are often notably worser than center only because big amount of lenses are way under designed and corrected. Unlike in Oly E-system whose lenses kept quality good all the way to corners.
> Corrections done before light gets to sensor are lossless
If optical corrections are lossless, then digital processing should be able to improve those degrading corners.
Corrections done before lights gets to sensor require extra layers of glass. More layers of attenuation, and more surfaces for reflections and scattering. That’s not lossless, at least as far as image quality is concerned!
Optical correction and software (algorithmic) correction are both tools in the designer’s toolbox. It’s up to the designer how they are used, and to what end… higher quality, smaller size, or lower cost (pick any one), but they are each legitimate tools.
Putting software correction off limits is tying one hand behind your back. It’s like insisting on an all-analog signal path for audio… you are free to go that way if you like, but doing so instantly brands you as an ideologue.
I thought all Olympus mft lens have no need on in camera correction.
It depends what you call “In camera corrections” I own mft olympus 9-18 and use it with GH1 and chromatic aberrations are very important…I always correct them in lightroom
Guess what is the latest camera with built-in digital correction for aberration? Canon EOS 1D X!
The problem with micro four thirds is that Olympus does not correct for chromatic aberations while Panasonic does and even designs their lenses with this software correction in mind. Both companies though correct for distortion.
Software correction is the future though. Canon is doing it and now Sony is doing it. And unless computers disappear I don’t see how software corrected lenses can become absolete.
For all the love Leica receives they actually do it too. They have to fix the corners of their lenses with software corrections. Their lenses also cost thousands of dollars.
No one has provided any proof either that optical correction is always better than software correction.
I have some doubts that olympus doesn’t correct chromatic aberrations. I have olympus 9-18 on GH1 and chromatic aberrations are high, I think it is not the case on olympus bodies but I’m not sure…
“The problem with micro four thirds is that Olympus does not correct for chromatic aberations while Panasonic does and even designs their lenses with this software correction in mind. Both companies though correct for distortion.”
What you write is correct, except for the point about Panasonic designing with CA software correction in mind. The 20mm f/1.7 shows very little CA on my E-PL1, so it is clearly a good optical design in terms of CA. A Panasonic camera will correct whatever small level of CA is left.
I wish Olympus offer software correction for chromatic aberation. Why they don’t do it? 9-18 is a great lens, if it’s software corrected better.
Lens correction yes/no had been discussed to death after the launch of m43. It’s part of the system standard, and you’re free to use Leica lenses if you are not happy with corrected lenses. All manufacturers now use digital correction in various degrees. Get over it or move on.
The issue here is that Panasonic lenses are not fully supported regarding correction by Oly bodies. THAT is an issue and should be treated to maintain m43 as a compatible system.
Why isn’t the lens corrected on oly-houses? I thought this kind of correction was part of the standard?
Oly bodies also correct lens distorsion, as a system standard. Pana additionally corrects CA. Why Oly doesn’t…only the gods know…
You misunderstand. This lens is software corrected on Oly body. (Not CA)
The problem is this lens can’t focus well with Olympus body for unknown reason.
We have to wait more report for this issue.
Ah, thank you, that is clarifying indeed. Hopefully such a problem can be solved in firmware.
Wow, this site is incredible. A lot of information and comparison.
True, about the perfect balance… Congratulations @ Admin !
Can’t believe a couple of comments about software correction dominated this thread. Some of the first pics from the x zoom and everyone’s talking about correction. It’s a m43 lens, so that issue is as relevant as saying film is more optically pure.
Hi, guys, just stop arguing about or making comparison of leica to m43 or any other brands. I don’t understand why people keep judging that Leica is just trying to protect the reputation or whatever it is. If you guys think M43 is better , than let it be, or if you think Leica is better, again, let it be.
Stop comparing, people enjoy what they want to deserve. They are just tools, and remember, it all depends how the photographer use it. Its like a piano, some people like using a electronic keyboard and some like the classic piano. But what I can say is, there are just a group of idiot being jealous of the Leica users. By using different of excuse judging this brand. Come on guys, get a life. Who freaking cares as long as you can take a good photo.
PS: I know the girl inside this video, she is one of my best friend